An Atlas of Money · All entries
Oxhide copper ingots in Thrace
Supported Little disputed
Open on the mapLate Bronze Age copper ingots of the Mediterranean oxhide shape reached the eastern Balkans in the 14th century BC. Most analysed ones are Cypriot copper, though one scholar argues some could be local.
No state involved
No one's debt

Claims and evidence
Present-day Bulgaria has the highest concentration of oxhide ingots in south-east Europe, and archaeometry shows 'unequivocally' that all are Cypriot copper despite local deposits; they were likely symbolic gifts or prestige tokens rather than raw material. Supported Little disputed
- Popov, 'Metals in Thrace from the Early Chalcolithic to the End of the Bronze Age', Getty (2024), p. 20
Counter-model: the Strandzha is a rich copper region (250+ mines) and a 'metal road' carried its copper to the Aegean; at least some Thracian oxhide ingots may be local copper. Supported Strongly disputed
Contested by Popov (2024); Athanassov et al. (2020): lead isotopes show Cypriot copper
- de Boer, 'A Bronze Age Metal-Road to Eastern Thrace?', Ancient West & East 1.2 (2002); de Boer (2010); Leshtakov (2007)
The lead isotopes of the Cherkovo ingot fall in the Old Cypriot field but local Zidarovo ores near Karnobat are very close, so its provenance is ambiguous; the 'three ingots' of the literature are one genuine ingot (the Kaliakra piece is an alloy lump, the Sozopol one a re-captioned photo). Supported Little disputed
- de Boer (2002), 443–454
The Şarköy deposit (14th–13th c. BC) north-east of the Thracian Chersonese holds a copper-ingot fragment with Mycenaean, West Anatolian and Levantine weapons, a point where imports entered Thrace via Troy. Attested
- Karadzhinov, Thracia Homerica (2024), p. 25, after Athanassov et al. (2020)
Seven whole or fragmentary oxhide ingots and one miniature are known from the eastern Balkans; five analysed are Cypriot, matching the Uluburun ingots, dated late 15th – early 13th c. BC (most likely 14th) and marked on Cyprus after casting. Attested
- Athanassov et al., A New Look at the Late Bronze Age Oxhide Ingots from the Eastern Balkans (2020), pp. 302, 342–343
The ingots reached only the easternmost Balkans because skilled metallurgical communities lived there near Troy; their hoarding was a show of power by an old metallurgical elite who turned Mediterranean raw copper into another kind of valuable. Weak lead
- Athanassov et al. (2020)
Five whole oxhide ingots (about 25–27 kg each) are catalogued from Bulgaria: Ruse, Cherkovo, Chernozem and two from Kamenovo. De Boer's 2002 count of one genuine ingot predates the Chernozem (2002) and Kamenovo (2006) finds. Attested
“Oxhide ingot, four prominent tongue-shaped extensions, folded sides.”
Alexandrov et al. (eds), Gold and Bronze (NAIM-BAS 2018), catalogue nos 367-371, pp. 521-522