An Atlas of Money · All entries
Nigeria: multiple exchange rates and rationed dollars, 2015–23
Attested Little disputed
Open on the mapThe control: CBN circular TED/FEM/FPC/GEN/01/010: 'Inclusion of some imported goods and services on the list of items not valid for foreign exchange' (the '41 items') (2015-06-23). The gap between the official and the parallel rate: 2017-02: premium 60%; 2017-12: premium 20%; 2023-10 (end): premium >40%.
Imposed by the state
Issued, redeemable for nothing
Claims and evidence
The control: CBN circular TED/FEM/FPC/GEN/01/010: 'Inclusion of some imported goods and services on the list of items not valid for foreign exchange' (the '41 items') (2015-06-23). Attested Little disputed
“it has become imperative to exclude importers of some goods and services from accessing foreign exchange at the Nigerian foreign exchange markets”
CBN Trade and Exchange Department circular, 23 June 2015“an exchange restriction arising from the prohibition to access foreign exchange at the Nigerian foreign exchange markets for the payment of imports of 40 categories of items”
IMF Country Report No. 16/101, Nigeria: 2016 Article IV
The gap between the official and the parallel rate: 2017-02: premium 60%; 2017-12: premium 20%; 2023-10 (end): premium >40%. Supported Little disputed
“the parallel market premium declined from 60 percent in February 2017 to 20 percent in December 2017”
IMF Country Report No. 18/63, Nigeria: 2018 Article IV“market premium to about 20 percent against the official rate (N/$305), from a peak of 60 percent in February 2017”
IMF Country Report No. 18/63, Nigeria: 2018 Article IV“the parallel market rate depreciated by 35 percent between end-July and end-October to about 1,100, and the parallel market premium widened to over 40 percent.”
IMF Country Report No. 24/49, Nigeria: Post-Financing Assessment (February 2024)
Flight into bitcoin and other crypto via peer-to-peer platforms: After the CBN's February 2021 order to close exchanges' bank accounts, P2P bitcoin trade in Nigeria rose (Paxful and LocalBitcoins: US$80.6m to about US$103m per 90 days); Paxful cited capital controls on outflows. Supported Little disputed
“almost $103 million was traded in Nigeria in the past 90 day period on P2P exchanges Paxful and LocalBitcoins—up from $80.6 million three months before.”
Decrypt, 'Bitcoin Peer-to-Peer Trading Up 27% in Nigeria Since Crypto Ban' (2021), citing UsefulTulips“Stringent capital controls on outflows, high transaction costs on international transfers, and a minimum transaction limit of $100 on card payments on international websites are among the factors contributing to the popularity of crypto in Nigeria”
Decrypt, 'Bitcoin Peer-to-Peer Trading Up 27% in Nigeria Since Crypto Ban' (2021), citing UsefulTulips
Workaround: Importers of the excluded items were told to use 'their own funds', i.e. buy dollars outside the official market; the IMF recorded the resulting multiple-currency practice between the CBN rate and the BDC/parallel rates. Supported Little disputed
“an MCP arising from the large spread between the rate set by the CBN for commercial banks, and the rates in the BDC and parallel market”
IMF Country Report No. 16/101, Nigeria: 2016 Article IV
End (2023-06-14): The CBN abolished the segmentation of the FX market, moving all transactions to the I&E window with 'willing buyer, willing seller' pricing; the official rate fell about 60 percent toward the parallel rate, but a parallel premium reopened (>40% by end-October 2023). Attested Little disputed
“Abolishing the segmentation of the FX market into different windows. All transactions will now be done through the Investors and Exporters (I&E) window, where the exchange rate will be determined by market forces.”
Nairametrics, 'OFFICIAL: CBN announces unification of all exchange rate windows', 14 June 2023 (reporting CBN press release)“Immediately after unification of the official foreign exchange windows, the official exchange rate depreciated by 60 percent, converging to the parallel market rate.”
IMF Country Report No. 24/49, Nigeria: Post-Financing Assessment (February 2024)