An Atlas of Money · All entries
e-CNY: the digital cash phase
Attested Little disputed
Open on the mapChina's central bank designed the e-CNY as a central bank liability treated as cash (M0), paying no interest, with wallets tiered by identity, small anonymous wallets and programmability through smart contracts. Pilots were reported from 2019. In an October 2020 pilot in Shenzhen, lottery winnings in e-CNY were reported to expire if not spent in local stores by 18 October.
State-issued
Issued, redeemable for nothing
Claims and evidence
The People's Bank of China's 2021 paper calls the e-CNY the central bank's liability to the public, a substitute for M0 treated like physical cash, which pays no interest. Attested Little disputed
“Thirdly, e-CNY is the central bank’s liabilities to the public.”
PBoC Working Group on E-CNY R&D, Progress of Research & Development of E-CNY in China (July 2021), section 2; PDF p. 4“The e-CNY is a substitute for M0. Thus, it is treated the same as the physical RMB under M0, which carries and pays no interest.”
PBoC Working Group on E-CNY R&D, Progress of Research & Development of E-CNY in China (July 2021), sec. 3.2.2; PDF p. 8
Wallets are tiered by how strongly the holder is identified, with limits per transaction, per day and on the balance; the least-privileged wallets can be opened without giving an identity, under the principle of 'anonymity for small value and traceable for high value'. Attested Little disputed
“set per-transaction and daily limits as well as maximum balance according to the strength of real-name information”
PBoC Working Group on E-CNY R&D, Progress of Research & Development of E-CNY in China (July 2021), sec. 3.4.1; PDF p. 10“The least-privileged wallets can be opened without providing identities to reflect the principle of anonymity.”
PBoC Working Group on E-CNY R&D, Progress of Research & Development of E-CNY in China (July 2021), sec. 3.4.1; PDF p. 10“anonymity for small value and traceable for high value”
PBoC Working Group on E-CNY R&D, Progress of Research & Development of E-CNY in China (July 2021), sec. 3.2.5
The paper says the e-CNY 'obtains programmability from deploying smart contracts'. Attested Little disputed
“E-CNY obtains programmability from deploying smart contracts that don’t impair its monetary functions.”
PBoC Working Group on E-CNY R&D, Progress of Research & Development of E-CNY in China (July 2021), sec. 3.2.7; PDF p. 9
The paper says the central bank will keep supplying physical cash while there is demand for it. Attested Little disputed
“As long as there is demand for the physical RMB, the PBOC will neither stop supplying it, nor replace it via administrative order.”
PBoC Working Group on E-CNY R&D, Progress of Research & Development of E-CNY in China (July 2021), section 2
A Yicai commentary reports that pilots began in some cities in 2019 and were steadily widened. Supported Little disputed
“2019年起在部分城市开始试点并不断扩大试点范围”from 2019 pilots began in some cities, and the pilot area was steadily widened
Yicai, commentary on e-CNY 2.0 and the Lu Lei article, commentary
Forkast reported that winners of an e-CNY lottery in Shenzhen's Luohu district in October 2020 could spend it at over 3,300 local stores until 18 October, after which it expired. Supported Little disputed
“can now spend their digital yuan at over 3,300 stores in the Luohu District of Shenzhen until October 18. After that, the free e-money expires.”
Forkast, report of the Luohu digital yuan red-packet lottery (14 October 2020), para. 2