An Atlas of Money · All entries
Banco del Giro, Venice: state debt as bank money
Supported Disputed
Open on the mapThe Venetian Senate set up the Banco del Giro in 1619 to pay the state's creditors by crediting them with balances on its books. These balances, a transferable government debt, were legal tender for private debts and were kept in a ducat banco that matched no coin and stood at a premium over current coin. Napoleon's decree of 1806 liquidated the bank.
Imposed by the state
A claim on an issuer


Claims and evidence
By the Senate act of 3 May 1619 the Giro paid the state's creditors, first the silver supplier Giovanni Vendramin, by crediting them with deposits on its books. Roberds and Velde say it was meant not as a deposit bank but as a way to make a government debt easily transferable and so a means of payment. Supported Disputed
Contested by Dunbar (1892) read the 1619 act as setting up an ordinary deposit bank that happened to start with state liabilities.
“the creditors were paid by being credited with deposits on its books.”
C. F. Dunbar, 'The Bank of Venice', Quarterly Journal of Economics 6 (1892), 308-335, p. 324“it was not intended as a deposit bank, but rather a way to make a government debt easily transferable and thus turn it into a means of payment.”
Roberds, W. and F. R. Velde, 'Early Public Banks', Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta Working Paper 2014-9, p. 22
Giro balances were legal tender for private debts of 100 ducats or more from the start. The bank kept its accounts in a ducat banco that represented no coin and bore a premium over current money; from 1635 the government aimed to hold it at 20%. Convertibility lapsed from 1630 to 1666, when a reopened cash office ended forced payment by transfer. Napoleon decreed the liquidation of the bank's debts in 1806. Supported Little disputed
“From the start balances at the Giro were legal tender for private debts,”
Roberds, W. and F. R. Velde, 'Early Public Banks', Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta Working Paper 2014-9, p. 25“the bank used a money of account which bore this premium when rated in current money.”
C. F. Dunbar, 'The Bank of Venice', Quarterly Journal of Economics 6 (1892), 308-335, p. 330“The ducat banco represented no coin,”
C. F. Dunbar, 'The Bank of Venice', Quarterly Journal of Economics 6 (1892), 308-335, p. 330“bank money’s agio at a stable 20% relative to current money”
Roberds, W. and F. R. Velde, 'Early Public Banks', Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta Working Paper 2014-9, p. 25“from 1630 to 1666, when the opening of the cash office put an end to the forced payment by transfer of bank credits.”
C. F. Dunbar, 'The Bank of Venice' (note), Quarterly Journal of Economics 7 (1893), 210-212, p. 211“Napoleon issued his decree for the liquidation of the debts of the Bancogiro,”
C. F. Dunbar, 'The Bank of Venice', Quarterly Journal of Economics 6 (1892), 308-335, p. 329
In the war of Candia a second crisis broke out in 1648 and convertibility was suspended in fact, the agio falling to -3%. Supported Little disputed
“A second crisis soon erupted in 1648, and convertibility was de facto suspended, with the agio falling to -3%.”
Roberds, W. and F. R. Velde, 'Early Public Banks', Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta Working Paper 2014-9, Banco del Giro section
In the Ottoman war of 1714-18 payments were suspended in 1714 and the agio fell to -7% by 1718; Dunbar has the cash office closed and specie payments suspended from 1717 to 1739. Supported Little disputed
“payments were suspended in 1714 and the agio fell to -7% by 1718.”
Roberds, W. and F. R. Velde, 'Early Public Banks', Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta Working Paper 2014-9, Banco del Giro section“closed and specie payments suspended, from 1717 to 1739,”
C. F. Dunbar, 'The Bank of Venice', Quarterly Journal of Economics 6 (1892), 308-335, p. 328