An Atlas of Money · All entries
Chicago Plan for 100% reserve money
Attested
Open on the mapIn 1933, University of Chicago economists (Knight, Mints, Schultz, Simons and others) proposed in memoranda to abolish fractional-reserve banking and impose 100% reserves on demand deposits.
Claims and evidence
In 1933, University of Chicago economists (Knight, Mints, Schultz, Simons and others) proposed in memoranda to abolish fractional-reserve banking and impose 100% reserves on demand deposits. Attested
Contested by Rejected in practice: Congress chose federal deposit insurance (1933) and the Banking Act of 1935, which capped reserve requirements and so barred 100% reserves (Phillips 1992).
“the 1933 proposal put forward in a series of memoranda by economists at the University of Chicago to abolish the fractional reserve system and impose 100% reserves on demand deposits.”
Phillips, R. J. 1992. 'The "Chicago Plan" and New Deal Banking Reform.' Jerome Levy Economics Institute Working Paper No. 76.
Federal deposit insurance cut bank failures from about 4,000 in 1933 to 61 in 1934, removing the urgency for 100% reserves. The Banking Act of 1935 capped reserve requirements at twice the 1935 level. Attested Little disputed
Contested by Defenders of the plan (Phillips 1992; Benes and Kumhof 2012) say deposit insurance shifted risk to taxpayers.
“Federal deposit insurance was a program which had worked to restore to confidence in the banking system and assured little opposition to the establishment of permanent deposit insurance.”
Phillips (1992), Levy WP 76.
An IMF working paper by Benes and Kumhof (2012) models the Chicago Plan in a calibrated DSGE model of the US. It finds support for all four of Fisher's claimed benefits, including the elimination of bank runs, with output gains approaching 10%. Supported Strongly disputed
Contested by Model result, not evidence. The paper 'should not be reported as representing the views of the IMF'. Fractional-reserve and banking-school critics dispute the costs of transition and the loss of bank credit creation (no critique was fetched here).
“It envisaged the separation of the monetary and credit functions of the banking system, by requiring 100% reserve backing for deposits.”
Benes, J. and M. Kumhof. 2012. 'The Chicago Plan Revisited.' IMF Working Paper WP/12/202.