An Atlas of Money · All entries
Rothbard, The Case for a 100 Percent Gold Dollar (1962)
Supported Strongly disputed
Open on the mapRothbard argued that issuing promises to pay on demand beyond the goods on hand is fraud that the law should treat as such. He proposed 100% reserves in gold, in contrast with the Chicago School's 100% fiat-paper plan.
Claims and evidence
Rothbard argued that issuing promises to pay on demand beyond the goods on hand is fraud that the law should treat as such. He proposed 100% reserves in gold, in contrast with the Chicago School's 100% fiat-paper plan. Supported Strongly disputed
Contested by Selgin and White (1996) reply that fractional reserves are fraud only if a bank says, or contracts, that it holds 100% reserves.
“In my view, issuing promises to pay on demand in excess of the amount of goods on hand is simply fraud, and should be so considered by the legal system.”
Rothbard, M. N. 1962. 'The Case for a 100 Percent Gold Dollar.' In L. B. Yeager (ed.), In Search of a Monetary Constitution. Harvard UP. Mises Institute reprint 2001.
In The Mystery of Banking (1983), Rothbard restates the aim of enforcing 100% reserves. He accepts free banking as a second-best, because outlawing fractional reserves is hard to enforce. Supported Strongly disputed
Contested by Selgin and White (1996); White's free-banking defence of fractional reserves.
“While the outlawing of fractional reserve as fraud would be preferable if it could be enforced, the problems of enforcement, especially where banks can continually innovate in forms of credit, make free banking an attractive alternative.”
Rothbard, M. N. 1983. The Mystery of Banking, ch. XVII.
Free-banking theorists Selgin and White argue that fractional reserves are fraudulent only when a bank claims, or contracts, to hold 100% reserves. Banning such contracts restricts freedom of contract. Supported Strongly disputed
Contested by Rothbard (1962, 1983), Hoppe (1994), Huerta de Soto (1995, 1998).
“If a bank does not represent or expressly oblige itself to hold 100 percent reserves, then fractional reserves do not violate the contractual agreement between the bank and its customer”
Selgin, G. A. and L. H. White. 1996. 'In Defense of Fiduciary Media, or, We are Not Devo(lutionists), We are Misesians!' Review of Austrian Economics 9(2): 83-107.