An Atlas of Money · All entries

The Narrow Bank (TNB USA Inc.)

Credit & ledger · 2017 – 2020 · New York (Federal Reserve Bank of New York); TNB chartered in Connecticut

Attested Little disputed

Open on the map

A narrow bank takes deposits and invests only in interest-paying reserves at the Fed, so it cannot suffer a run. TNB, chartered in Connecticut, applied in August 2017 for a Fed master account and was refused, which led to its suit against the New York Fed.

Role of the state Private, under state licence or control

Whose debt A claim on an issuer

Cochrane quotes the TNB complaint, e.g. 'In August 2017, therefore, TNB began the routine administrative process to open a Master Account with the FRBNY.' Plotted at the FRBNY in New York, the documented defendant and court city; TNB's own city is not given in the sources used. TNB alleges the Board countermanded the FRBNY's approval over 'policy concerns'. The suit was filed in 2018 (docket 18-cv-7978). Later history (appeal or new application) was not checked. This is the Fed's official counter-reading to the narrow-bank case.

Claims and evidence

A narrow bank takes deposits and invests only in interest-paying reserves at the Fed, so it cannot suffer a run. TNB, chartered in Connecticut, applied in August 2017 for a Fed master account and was refused, which led to its suit against the New York Fed. Attested Little disputed

Contested by Federal Reserve Board (ANPR, March 2019): such 'pass-through investment entities' would likely harm financial stability on net, by offering an unlimited safe haven in stress.

On 25 March 2020 the Southern District of New York (Judge Carter) dismissed TNB's suit on jurisdictional grounds: the FRBNY had neither formally nor constructively decided the application, so the claim was unripe. Attested

Contested by Not a question of fact. TNB argued that delay amounted to constructive denial.

The Federal Reserve Board stated that pass-through investment entities like TNB would likely harm financial stability on net. In its view, they would offer a nearly unlimited safe haven in stress and draw short-term funding away from firms and governments. Supported Strongly disputed

Contested by Cochrane (2018): 'completely misguided'. People can already run to Treasuries, and narrow banks reduce run-prone short-term debt in the first place.