An Atlas of Money · All entries

Huizi: Southern Song paper money

Paper & fiat · 1160 – 1276 · Lin'an (Hangzhou)

Attested Little disputed

Open on the map

Private bills of Lin'an (Hangzhou) taken over by the state in 1160-61. Issued in three-year periods, the notes grew from 10 million strings an issue to hundreds of millions, lost value, and from 1264 were rated against a new note, the guanzi.

Role of the state State-issued

Whose debt A claim on an issuer

Print of a Song paper-money plate, valid everywhere 'except Sichuan' (除四川外) for 770 cash. Its wording fits a late Southern Song note, huizi or guanzi; no surviving text quotes the plate, so the issue is not known
Print of a Song paper-money plate, valid everywhere 'except Sichuan' (除四川外) for 770 cash. Its wording fits a late Southern Song note, huizi or guanzi; no surviving text quotes the plate, so the issue is not known — John E. Sandrock, Public domain

Claims and evidence

Huizi began as private bills. Li Xinchuan writes that in the late Shaoxing years (c. 1160) the people of Lin'an (Hangzhou) privately issued 'convenient-cash huizi' (bianqian huizi), run by rich households. Qian Duanli, prefect of Lin'an, took the business over for the government, and as vice-minister of revenue issued the notes from his ministry. In the 2nd month of 1161 a state huizi office opened in the capital; the notes were to pass in the southeastern circuits like cash for tax and army payments, and 100,000 strings from the Left Treasury were granted as their reserve. Song shi dates the order to Qian Duanli to 1160: cash was to be stored and the notes circulated inside and outside the city. Attested Little disputed

From 1168 huizi were issued in numbered issue periods (jie 界) of three years, capped at 10 million strings each: new notes were printed to replace old ones, a fee of 20 cash was charged per note exchanged, and worn notes were exchanged if the value and seal could still be read. Taxes could be paid partly in notes (in one rule of 1169, 7 parts cash to 3 parts notes). Counterfeiting carried the death penalty from 1162. The figures given to the court in 1167: 28 million notes printed from 1161 to mid-1166, 15.6 million paid out, 9.8 million in the hands of the public; in 1166 the court spent 1 million taels of silver from the palace treasuries buying notes back. Around 1176, of 12 million strings of annual revenue half came in as notes, 4 million had been bought in by the Southern Treasury with gold and silver, and only 2 million were circulating. Attested Little disputed

The issue limits did not hold. Issue periods were extended (in 1190 the 7th and 8th to nine years, and an official asked 'how can that show good faith?'); the size of each issue rose from 10 million strings to 18 million, then to 23.2 million for the 7th; in 1195 the cap was set at 30 million; the 11th issue came to 36.3 million and the 13th, after the war of 1206, to 47.6 million, with three issues in use at once. In 1209 the 11th issue still had 13.6 million outstanding and the 12th and 13th over 100 million; old notes were exchanged two for one new. By 1232 two issues together came to over 229 million. In 1247 the 17th and 18th issues were declared valid for ever, with no end date. Li Xinchuan reports that around 1202 a note of 1,000 fetched about 750 copper cash in Jiangnan and Zhejiang, and in 1210 about 700 in the capital and half that in the provinces. Attested Little disputed

Two Song writers say that as notes spread, copper coin went out of use. Li Xinchuan (1216): in the early 1130s armies were paid in cash, but within sixty years of Qian Duanli's notes little cash was left in public or private hands, 'because paper notes circulate everywhere and copper is hoarded and not used'. Ma Duanlin (1307): after 1209 grain purchases, salt funds, officials' salaries and soldiers' pay were all in paper, and copper cash was treasured because it was rarely seen. Attested Little disputed

In the 10th month of 1264, under Jia Sidao, the falling 17th issue was called in for the 18th within one month, and a new note, the guanzi, was issued at 77 cash per hundred (770 per string), one guanzi to three 18th-issue huizi. Jia Sidao's biography says the new silver guanzi made prices rise further and the notes cheaper still. In 1268 each 18th-issue note was fixed at 257 cash, three to one guanzi, with officials who discounted it to be punished as for bribery. The huizi of the 18th issue thus ran on beside the guanzi. Attested Little disputed

Connections