An Atlas of Money · All entries

'Whose?': sharing by blind lot

Commodity · 1789 – 1912 · At sea and on the polar ice (Bounty launch, Antarctic sledge journeys)

Attested Little disputed

Open on the map

Bligh in the Bounty's launch (1789) and later Antarctic sledgers divided food into equal heaps; one man turned his back and named the owner of each heap as another pointed and asked 'Whose?'.

Role of the state No state involved

No trading of rations is recorded on these journeys. Shackleton adds that each man felt sure the smallest share had fallen to him.

Claims and evidence

In the Bounty's launch, food was divided by one man turning his back while another pointed to each portion and asked 'Who shall have this?', the first naming someone. Attested Little disputed

On Shackleton's southern journey (1908–09), once all agreed the divisions were equal, one man turned his back and another, pointing at a lot, asked 'Whose?'. Attested Little disputed

Mawson calls this the usual sledging practice: food divided into even halves, then one man turns away and the other, pointing to a heap, asks 'Whose?'. Attested Little disputed

Connections