An Atlas of Money · All entries
Da Ming Baochao
Attested Little disputed
Open on the mapInconvertible Ming notes, issued without limit. By the mid-15th century they were nearly worthless, and China turned to silver.
State-issued
Issued, redeemable for nothing

Claims and evidence
Ming paper money lost almost all value by c. 1450, and silver took over. Attested Little disputed
- Von Glahn, Fountain of Fortune (1996)
“In 1448, and with a view of improving the credit of the government paper notes, the circulation of metallic chuen was prohibited ; but this measure proved abortive, and by the year 1455 the paper issues appear to have become entirely discredited, and metallic chuen resumed their old place in the circulation. This was the last issue of impe- rial government notes in China.”
Del Mar, History of Money in Ancient Countries (1885) [candidate new leg], p. 32“but since, in point of fact, these metals were not | then coined or used as money in China, neither their use nor disuse could have had any effect”
Del Mar, History of Money in Ancient Countries (1885) [candidate new leg], p. 31