An Atlas of Money · All entries

Cíbola, 1539: turquoise and hides for labour (reported)

Commodity · 1539 · Cíbola (the Zuni towns; placed at Hawikuh), New Mexico

Supported Disputed

Open on the map

In 1539 Fray Marcos de Niza, travelling north towards Cíbola, asked people he met how they came by the turquoise and bison hides they had. They told him it was by the sweat and service of their persons: they went to Cíbola, dug the fields and did other work there, and were given hides and turquoise for their service. The report reached the Spanish only through Fray Marcos, and a year later Coronado wrote of him that 'he has not told the truth in a single thing that he said'. Winship (1896) thought the informants more likely dug their turquoise themselves. If the report is right, turquoise and hides were paid as wages, with no state behind them.

Role of the state No state role recorded

Whose debt No one's debt

Plan of the ruins of Hawikuh, by Victor Mindeleff, Bureau of Ethnology, published 1891
Plan of the ruins of Hawikuh, by Victor Mindeleff, Bureau of Ethnology, published 1891 — VICTOR MINDELEFF, Public domain

Claims and evidence

Fray Marcos reports that people on his way north told him they got their turquoise and bison hides by their own labour: they went to Cíbola, dug the fields and did other work there, and were given hides and turquoise for their service. Coronado wrote a year later that Fray Marcos had not told the truth in a single thing, and Winship thought the turquoise was more likely dug by the informants themselves. Supported Disputed

Contested by Coronado, letter of 3 August 1540: Fray Marcos 'has not told the truth in a single thing that he said'; Winship (1896): the informants more likely dug the turquoise themselves

Connections