An Atlas of Money · All entries
Ur III: silver and barley as money
Attested Disputed
Open on the mapUr III accountants converted goods and labour into silver equivalents; a shekel of silver (c. 8.33 g) fetched 300 l barley, 30 l fish oil, 10 l butter or a sheep; trade-agent (damgar) accounts were balanced entirely in silver equivalences (Englund 2012).
No one's debt
Claims and evidence
Ur III accountants converted goods and labour into silver equivalents; a shekel of silver (c. 8.33 g) fetched 300 l barley, 30 l fish oil, 10 l butter or a sheep; trade-agent (damgar) accounts were balanced entirely in silver equivalences (Englund 2012). Attested Disputed
Contested by Debate over whether equivalences were state-imposed ('command economy', Englund 2012) or market-formed prices; Englund himself argues for state-administered equivalences. Opposing market-oriented readings (e.g.
“A shekel of silver (ca. 8.33 g) fetched 300 liters of barley, 30 liters of fish oil, 10 liters of clarified butter, or a healthy sheep.”
Englund, R. K., 'Equivalency Values and the Command Economy of the Ur III Period in Mesopotamia', in Papadopoulos & Urton (eds), The Construction of Value in the Ancient World (2012), pp. 427-458; abstract p. 427
Englund (2012) notes that in payments to day labourers and in informal transactions barley equated to work time and to other commodities, functioning as 'so-called commodity money' (citing Widell 2005). Attested Little disputed
“barley equated to both work time and, like silver in state accounts, any of a number of commodities sought by these individuals (so-called commodity money; cf. Widell 2005:397–398)”
Englund, R. K., 'Equivalency Values and the Command Economy of the Ur III Period in Mesopotamia' (2012), p. 434 approx. (section on equivalency types)