An Atlas of Money · All entries

India 2016: demonetisation (coercive note withdrawal)

Paper & fiat · 2016 – 2018 · New Delhi, India

Attested Little disputed

Open on the map

A coercive note withdrawal in a democracy, not a restrictive regime: on 8 November 2016 the government declared 86% of currency in circulation illegal tender overnight, with new notes introduced over months; districts hit harder saw falls in activity and faster adoption of electronic payments.

Role of the state Imposed by the state

Whose debt Issued, redeemable for nothing

Gopinath was later IMF chief economist; open NBER WP. Paper cites RBI (2016) circulars.

Claims and evidence

A coercive note withdrawal in a democracy, not a restrictive regime: on 8 November 2016 the government declared 86% of currency in circulation illegal tender overnight, with new notes introduced over months; districts hit harder saw falls in activity and faster adoption of electronic payments. Attested Little disputed

State response: exchange of old notes was capped at Rs 4,000 per person per day, bank withdrawals at Rs 10,000/day and Rs 20,000/week, ATM withdrawals at Rs 2,000/day; limits were relaxed and removed on 30 January 2017. Attested

Almost all demonetised notes came back: by RBI's 2018 count 99% of old 500 and 1000 notes were returned, 97% by end-December 2016, undercutting the premise that much cash was unreturnable 'black money'. Attested Disputed

Contested by Indian government argued an important fraction of cash was black money held for tax evasion; the near-total return is read by critics as showing the policy failed that aim.