An Atlas of Money · All entries
US stamp scrip, 1932-34
Supported Little disputed
Open on the mapAmerican stamp scrip began at Hawarden, Iowa, in October 1932 with $300 in $1 certificates, each redeemable in cash once 36 three-cent stamps had been put on it, one at each transfer. Most merchants took it; the banks did not. Towns reported fast turnover, but the undated design taxed spending rather than holding, and buyers and sellers could agree to skip the stamp. Under an Iowa act of 1933 counties issued stamp notes; Polk County's, the largest issue, circulated slowly and was retired by bond issue. Harper's thesis (1948) counted 95 stamp-scrip issues, mostly of $300 to $500.
State-issued
A claim on an issuer
Claims and evidence
Hawarden issued $300 of $1 stamp scrip in October 1932. One stamp was to be put on at each transfer, so the redemption date was open. Most merchants took it; the banks did not. Supported Little disputed
“So, in October 1932, upon petition, the town decided to issue $300 in Stamp Scrip of $1.00 denomination.”
Irving Fisher, Stamp Scrip (New York: Adelphi, 1933), ch. V, 'Hawarden, Iowa'“The agreement is merely that one stamp is to be affixed with each transfer of the scrip, so that the redemption date is indeterminate.”
Irving Fisher, Stamp Scrip (New York: Adelphi, 1933), ch. V, 'Hawarden, Iowa'“However, they were not accepted by the banks.”
Vernon L. Brown, Scrip and Other Forms of Emergency Currency Issued in the United States during the Depression Years of 1931-1934, MBA thesis, New York University, 1941, 2 vols., vol. I, p. 53, Hawarden
Fisher thought the undated plan ill-advised: it charged for passing the scrip on rather than for holding it, and gave both parties a motive to omit the stamp. At Evanston the chain stores agreed with customers to take and give the scrip without stamps. Supported Little disputed
“since it costs 3 cents to transfer the scrip instead of costing 3 cents not to transfer it!”
Irving Fisher, Stamp Scrip (New York: Adelphi, 1933), ch. V, 'Hawarden, Iowa'“the chain stores made a flank attack on the local merchants by agreeing with their patrons to receive the scrip, without stamps, provided the patrons would receive them back without stamps.”
Irving Fisher, Stamp Scrip (New York: Adelphi, 1933), ch. V, 'Evanston, Illinois'
Local officers reported turnover of once every three days at Russell, Kansas, and once every four days at Rock Rapids, Iowa, where people were reluctant to take the scrip; Evanston reported four times a week over a short period. Supported Little disputed
“a check-up seems to show an average turnover of once every three days.”
Irving Fisher, Stamp Scrip (New York: Adelphi, 1933), ch. V, 'Russell, Kansas'“People are reluctant to take the scrip from the merchants, but the turnover seems to be once every four days.”
Irving Fisher, Stamp Scrip (New York: Adelphi, 1933), ch. V, 'Rock Rapids, Iowa'“Evanston, Illinois, reported an average velocity of four times per week over a short period.”
Bruce Champ, 'Stamp Scrip: Money People Paid to Use', Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland Economic Commentary, April 2008, p. 4
Iowa counties issued stamp notes under a 1933 act. Polk County's issue, the largest, is put at about $135,000 by Brown (1941) and at $120,688 by Champ (2008, from Harper). The notes circulated slowly, merchants refused them, and all were redeemed by bond issue. Supported Disputed
Contested by The size of the Polk County issue: about $135,000 in Brown (1941); $120,688 in Champ (2008), citing Harper (1948).
“Polk County issued about $135,000 but according to Mr. Zylstra, there was not enough publicity and public education to make it function smoothly.”
Vernon L. Brown, Scrip and Other Forms of Emergency Currency Issued in the United States during the Depression Years of 1931-1934, MBA thesis, New York University, 1941, 2 vols., vol. I, p. 54“Other counties had the same experience, the notes circulated slowly, and merchants refused to accept it.”
Vernon L. Brown, Scrip and Other Forms of Emergency Currency Issued in the United States during the Depression Years of 1931-1934, MBA thesis, New York University, 1941, 2 vols., vol. I, p. 54, Iowa county stamp notes“The largest municipal issue ($120,688) was in Polk County, Iowa, but it ultimately failed.”
Bruce Champ, 'Stamp Scrip: Money People Paid to Use', Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland Economic Commentary, April 2008, p. 3
Mason City put $10,000 into circulation from May 1933 and ended the scheme in August 1934; 49 firms had bought $6,966 of the $10,620.22 in stamps sold, which the Chamber of Commerce took as proof that the certificates did not circulate fast. Supported Little disputed
“As proof of this, 49 firms bought and paid for $6,966 of the $10,620.22 worth of stamps sold.”
Vernon L. Brown, Scrip and Other Forms of Emergency Currency Issued in the United States during the Depression Years of 1931-1934, MBA thesis, New York University, 1941, 2 vols., vol. I, p. 55, Mason City“In August, 1934, Mason City wrote finis to the chapter of "stamp money."”
Vernon L. Brown, Scrip and Other Forms of Emergency Currency Issued in the United States during the Depression Years of 1931-1934, MBA thesis, New York University, 1941, 2 vols., vol. I, p. 55, Mason City
Harper's 1948 thesis, as summarised by Champ, found 95 stamp-scrip issues by 37 cities, 8 counties and many business groups; most were of $300 to $500 and none above $2,000 succeeded. Supported Little disputed
“Harper, in his unpublished 1948 Ph.D. thesis about the scrip of the 1930s, found 95 specific issues of stamp scrip by 37 cities, 8 counties, and numerous business groups.”
Bruce Champ, 'Stamp Scrip: Money People Paid to Use', Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland Economic Commentary, April 2008, p. 3