An Atlas of Money · All entries
Shetland, 1872: the truck system
Attested Little disputed
Open on the mapThe Truck Commissioner's inquiry of 1871–72 found that many Shetland tenants were bound by their landlord, often also the fish-curer, to deliver their fish to him, on pain of eviction or a fine called 'liberty money'. Fish, store goods and rent were settled together once a year, and in the season the fishermen got goods, not money, from the curer's store. Knitting was by custom paid in goods 'from Unst to Dunrossness', and eggs and butter went to the shop for goods. Because the fishermen were paid a price for their fish, not wages, the Truck Act did not reach them.
Imposed by the state
A claim on an issuer
Claims and evidence
A fisherman told the commissioner that they were bound to deliver their fish to the landlord, and that they settled with him once a year for the fishing, the store goods and the rent together. Attested Little disputed
“There is one thing we complain of: that we are bound to deliver our fish, wet or green, to the landlord.”
Guthrie, W., Report of the Commissioner appointed under the Truck Commission Act 1870 to inquire into the Truck System in Shetland (Parliamentary Papers, 1872), evidence of Laurence Mail, Q. 559“We settle once a year with him for our fishing, and for the store goods we have got, and rent and everything together.”
Guthrie, W., Report of the Commissioner appointed under the Truck Commission Act 1870 to inquire into the Truck System in Shetland (Parliamentary Papers, 1872), Q. 565
Where tenants were bound to fish for the landlord, they were firmly convinced that the penalty for disobeying was eviction or a payment of 'liberty money'. Attested Little disputed
“In all the cases where tenants are bound to fish for the landlord, there is a firm conviction that the penalty of disobedience is eviction, or payment of 'liberty money.'”
Guthrie, W., Report of the Commissioner appointed under the Truck Commission Act 1870 to inquire into the Truck System in Shetland (Parliamentary Papers, 1872), Report, 'Eviction and liberty money'
Witnesses said they had no money to buy at other stores because they got no money in the fishing season. The commissioner found that a curer scarcely tried to hide that the earnings of those he employed were paid largely in goods. Attested Little disputed
“Because we had no money to purchase them with from other stores. We received no money during the fishing season.”
Guthrie, W., Report of the Commissioner appointed under the Truck Commission Act 1870 to inquire into the Truck System in Shetland (Parliamentary Papers, 1872), evidence of Malcolm Malcolmson, Q. 3005“he scarcely ever seeks to conceal the fact that the earnings of those whom he employs are paid to a large extent, in goods”
Guthrie, W., Report of the Commissioner appointed under the Truck Commission Act 1870 to inquire into the Truck System in Shetland (Parliamentary Papers, 1872), Report, 'Truck system - advances and settlements'
The Truck Act did not protect the fishermen, because they did not receive wages but were paid a price for their fish. Attested Little disputed
“they do not receive wages, but are paid a price for their fish.”
Guthrie, W., Report of the Commissioner appointed under the Truck Commission Act 1870 to inquire into the Truck System in Shetland (Parliamentary Papers, 1872), Report, 'Truck system - advances and settlements'
Knitting was paid in goods by the custom of the country from Unst to Dunrossness, and formerly money payment was never thought of. One knitter said she had asked for a penny out of 35s. and been refused. Attested Little disputed
“In both branches of the trade, it is the custom and understanding of the country, from Unst to Dunrossness, that payment shall be made in goods. Formerly money payment was never thought of.”
Guthrie, W., Report of the Commissioner appointed under the Truck Commission Act 1870 to inquire into the Truck System in Shetland (Parliamentary Papers, 1872), Report, 'Knitting paid in goods'“I asked for a penny the last time out of 35s., and they refused to give it to me.”
Guthrie, W., Report of the Commissioner appointed under the Truck Commission Act 1870 to inquire into the Truck System in Shetland (Parliamentary Papers, 1872), evidence of Margaret Williamson, Q. 8315
Farmers' wives took eggs and butter to the shop and seldom thought of asking money for them, though the commissioner found no sign that money would have been refused if asked for. Attested Little disputed
“She takes the eggs and butter to the shop, and seldom thinks of getting money for them.”
Guthrie, W., Report of the Commissioner appointed under the Truck Commission Act 1870 to inquire into the Truck System in Shetland (Parliamentary Papers, 1872), Report, 'Eggs, butter, etc.'“but it does not appear that money would be refused if asked for.”
Guthrie, W., Report of the Commissioner appointed under the Truck Commission Act 1870 to inquire into the Truck System in Shetland (Parliamentary Papers, 1872), Report, 'Eggs, butter, etc.'
A merchant at Bayhall in Walls told the commissioner in 1872 that eggs were looked upon as money: he charged the same price for his goods whether they were paid for in eggs or in money, and dealt in barter for eggs because he took them to be the same as money. If a seller wanted cash instead, he paid a halfpenny less per dozen. A shopkeeper at Whiteness made the same difference of a halfpenny a dozen. Attested Little disputed
“Yes; eggs are looked upon as money. We make no difference upon the price of our goods whether they are paid for in eggs or money.”
Guthrie, W., Report of the Commissioner appointed under the Truck Commission Act 1870 to inquire into the Truck System in Shetland (Parliamentary Papers, 1872), evidence of George Georgeson, merchant, Bayhall, Walls, Q. 12,038 (Lerwick, 24 January 1872)“except in eggs and hosiery, our trade is principally for cash and we deal in barter for eggs because we look upon them as being the same as money.”
Guthrie, W., Report of the Commissioner appointed under the Truck Commission Act 1870 to inquire into the Truck System in Shetland (Parliamentary Papers, 1872), Georgeson, Q. 12,047“If they want cash, and we pay a few shillings in cash, then we pay a halfpenny less per dozen for the eggs”
Guthrie, W., Report of the Commissioner appointed under the Truck Commission Act 1870 to inquire into the Truck System in Shetland (Parliamentary Papers, 1872), Georgeson, Q. 12,049“Yes; there is a difference of 1/2d. per dozen, as a general rule.”
Guthrie, W., Report of the Commissioner appointed under the Truck Commission Act 1870 to inquire into the Truck System in Shetland (Parliamentary Papers, 1872), evidence of Archibald Abernethy, shopkeeper, Whiteness, Tingwall, Q. 12,255
A Lerwick merchant who tried to buy fowls in Sandwick parish was told that, although he offered about twice their value, none could be bought, because the tenants, who had no leases, were bound by agreement with the landlord to deliver so many fowls to him about February. He thought it was something over and above the rent, a present for being allowed to sit without leases; asked whether it was not part of the rent, as kain was formerly paid and still was in parts of Scotland, he said he did not think so, since no rent account he knew marked it down. Attested Little disputed
“it was an agreement between landlord and tenants, although the tenants had no leases whatever, that they had to deliver so many fowls about the month of February to the landlord.”
Guthrie, W., Report of the Commissioner appointed under the Truck Commission Act 1870 to inquire into the Truck System in Shetland (Parliamentary Papers, 1872), evidence of John Harrison, merchant, Lerwick, Q. 16,461 (6 February 1872)“although I had offered about twice the value for each of the fowls, he had found it quite impossible to purchase them”
Guthrie, W., Report of the Commissioner appointed under the Truck Commission Act 1870 to inquire into the Truck System in Shetland (Parliamentary Papers, 1872), Harrison, Q. 16,461“my impression is that it was something over and above the rent, as a present for being allowed to sit without leases.”
Guthrie, W., Report of the Commissioner appointed under the Truck Commission Act 1870 to inquire into the Truck System in Shetland (Parliamentary Papers, 1872), Harrison, Q. 16,461“Was not that just part of the rent as kain was formerly paid, and is now paid in some parts of Scotland?”
Guthrie, W., Report of the Commissioner appointed under the Truck Commission Act 1870 to inquire into the Truck System in Shetland (Parliamentary Papers, 1872), the commissioner's question, Q. 16,462
Connections
- Labrador: the truck system
- Truck Act 1831: wages in coin, not goods
- Lerwick, 1872: merchants' 'lines' passed as currency
- Shetland: scat and rents in wadmal, butter and oil
- Shetland, 1700–1809: stockings bartered, foreign coin current
- Mexico, before 1867: soap in the towns and eggs in the country as small change