An Atlas of Money · All entries

Bank suspensions of specie payment (1814; 1837; 1857)

Credit & ledger · 1814 – 1857 · Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

Attested Little disputed

Open on the map

In August 1814 the federal government, and the state governments outside New England, let insolvent banks suspend specie payment and keep operating. The suspension lasted until February 1817.

Role of the state Private, under state licence or control

Whose debt A claim on an issuer

'Humbug Glory Bank': mock six-cent note parodying the shinplasters of the 1837 suspension
'Humbug Glory Bank': mock six-cent note parodying the shinplasters of the 1837 suspension — Fleetwood, Anthony, approximately 1800-, Public domain

Calomiris & Gorton (1991, Table 4.1) date the 1857 panic to October 1857. Gorton & Tallman (2016, n.21) note that suspension was announced in New York City in 1857 and was a suspension of note redemption for specie. Calomiris & Gorton (1991, Table 4.1) date the panic to May 1837. Place: the New York City banks led the suspension (from standard histories; not stated in the local texts). Calomiris & Gorton (p. 110) also conclude that 'banking panics are not inherent in banking contracts—institutional structure matters'. Both sides agree suspensions happened with official tolerance. They disagree on whether that was a harmful breach of contract or a stabilizing device. Place: suspension spread through the mid-Atlantic and South (Baltimore, Philadelphia, Washington) but not New England. Philadelphia is a representative anchor. Calomiris & Gorton (1991, Table 4.1) date this panic August 1814 to January 1817, suspension through February 1817. Rothbard calls this a failure of government to enforce contracts and property rights. He lists suspensions in 1819, 1837, 1839 and 1857.

Claims and evidence

In August 1814 the federal government, and the state governments outside New England, let insolvent banks suspend specie payment and keep operating. The suspension lasted until February 1817. Attested Little disputed

Austrian reading of state tolerance: the 1814 precedent meant that in every later crisis state and federal governments 'looked the other way' and allowed general suspensions. This encouraged inflationary expansion. Supported Disputed

Contested by Calomiris & Gorton 1991

Banks throughout the US, including the Bank of the United States, suspended specie payments in May 1837. Their notes depreciated and interregional trade was crippled. Attested

New York banks were compelled by law to resume, and other banks followed in the fall of 1838. Supported

Austrian reading: antebellum 'free banking' was not free, because government allowed periodic general suspensions, most recently in the panic of 1857. Supported Disputed

Contested by Calomiris & Gorton 1991

Opposing (institutional) reading: suspension, together with clearing-house arrangements, let banks keep lending instead of calling loans. Panics are not inherent in banking contracts; institutional structure matters. Supported Disputed

Contested by Rothbard 2002