An Atlas of Money · All entries

Coinage Act of 1873 ('Crime of '73')

Law & text · 1873 · Washington, D.C.

Attested

Open on the map

Congress revised the coinage laws in February 1873 and left out unlimited silver coinage, which put the US on a de facto gold standard after 81 years of bimetallism.

Role of the state State-issued

1873 trade dollar re-engraved as a satire on the 'Crime of '73': reverse reads SIXTEEN TO ONE NIT
1873 trade dollar re-engraved as a satire on the 'Crime of '73': reverse reads SIXTEEN TO ONE NIT — John Baumgart, CC0

Rothbard (p. 157) agrees on substance and adds the act of June 1874, which limited silver dollars' legal tender to $5. Rothbard, like the silverites, accepts that silver would otherwise have flowed in and the US would have gone onto silver. He treats the 1873-79 deflation as benign (see Panic of 1873 entry). Velde's own model finds bimetallism would have survived about 20 more years, with sharp early-20th-century inflation. Friedman 1990 (JPE) itself is paywalled and not read.

Claims and evidence

Congress revised the coinage laws in February 1873 and left out unlimited silver coinage, which put the US on a de facto gold standard after 81 years of bimetallism. Attested

Austrian reading: demonetization was a 'crime' in manner only. It was done shiftily by insiders who expected silver to fall, though Rothbard thinks the case for gold was strong. Supported Disputed

Contested by Velde 2002 (re Friedman 1990)

Opposing reading (Friedman 1990, revisited by Velde 2002): had the US kept free silver coinage at the old ratio, the price level would have been more stable. Supported Disputed

Contested by Rothbard 2002