An Atlas of Money · All entries

National Banking Acts (1863-64) and 10% tax on state bank notes (1865)

Law & text · 1863 – 1913 · Washington, D.C.

Attested

Open on the map

The national bank acts of 1863 and 1864 set up national banks chartered by the Comptroller of the Currency in Washington, D.C.

Role of the state Imposed by the state

Back of a $2 national bank note of the Saint Nicholas National Bank, New York, 1865
Back of a $2 national bank note of the Saint Nicholas National Bank, New York, 1865 — National Bank Note Co., producer ; Saint Nicholas National Bank, associated name ; New York (State), associated name ; Raleigh, Walter, Sir (1552?-1618, English) associated name, Public domain

Both readings agree on the bond-demand motive. They differ on whether the result was 'uniform currency' or cartelized pyramiding. Correction to Rothbard p. 122 ('the national banking system Act of 1863 forbade the issuance of any state bank notes'): per Fed History, the 1863 act imposed a 2% tax, and the 10% tax came in 1865. Rothbard's own p. 144 gives March 1865. The same index lists 'Mar. 3,1865. Taxation of State banks'. Rothbard: state banks fell from 1,466 (1863) to 297 (1866), then revived as deposit banks. Statute dates from the 1920 Senate compilation: Feb. 25, 1863 (national currency act) and June 3, 1864 (repealed and re-enacted). This is the Act of February 8, 1875 (sec. 19, 18 Stat. 311) re-enacting the 1865/1866 tax. The 1865 text itself was not retrieved.

Claims and evidence

The national bank acts of 1863 and 1864 set up national banks chartered by the Comptroller of the Currency in Washington, D.C. Attested

Primary statute: the Act of February 25, 1863 'to provide a national currency secured by a pledge of United States stocks'. Attested

From 1865 the national banks had a legal monopoly of bank-note issue, because the March 1865 10% tax made state notes prohibitive. Attested

Primary statute text: every non-national bank 'shall pay a tax of ten per centum' on its own notes used for circulation. Attested

The 1865 measure raised the tax on state bank notes to 10%, which effectively eliminated them: circulation fell from $143 million (1865) to $4 million (1867). Supported

Austrian reading: the Civil War system outlawed state notes and created a quasi-centralized fractional-reserve system that paved the way for the Federal Reserve. Supported Disputed

Contested by Federal Reserve History 2022 (National Banking Acts essay)

Sound-money (Griffin) reading: the national banks were a privileged 'halfway house to central banking'. Weak lead Disputed

Contested by Federal Reserve History 2022 (National Banking Acts essay)

Opposing (official-history) reading: the Acts were a wartime expedient to raise demand for federal debt and promote a stable, uniform currency, and they largely solved the non-uniform-currency problem. Supported Disputed

Contested by Rothbard 2002