An Atlas of Money · All entries

Panic of 1873

Credit & ledger · 1873 – 1879 · New York City (Wall Street district)

Attested

Open on the map

The failure of Jay Cooke's house, overextended in the Northern Pacific, set off the panic of 1873.

Role of the state Private, under state licence or control

Whose debt A claim on an issuer

Run on the Fourth National Bank, Nassau Street, New York; Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper, 4 Oct 1873
Run on the Fourth National Bank, Nassau Street, New York; Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper, 4 Oct 1873 — Unknown author Unknown author, Public domain

Jay Cooke & Co. was Philadelphia-based; the panic broke on Wall Street (September 18, 1873, from standard histories, not the local texts), so it is anchored at NYC. Calomiris & Gorton (Table 4.1) date it September 1873, the same month as the cycle peak. Griffin (approx. pp. 408-409) tells the same Cooke/Northern Pacific story. Rothbard relies on Friedman & Schwartz's own figures. Opposing open sources treat 1873 as a panic at a cycle peak but do not directly test the 'no depression' claim, so disagreement here is partly untested. This is Klein's wording quoted by Rothbard (and Griffin, line ~1205). Calomiris & Gorton likewise blame 'unit banking and reserve pyramiding', so disagreement on mechanism is low.

Claims and evidence

The failure of Jay Cooke's house, overextended in the Northern Pacific, set off the panic of 1873. Attested

Shared diagnosis (Klein, quoted by Rothbard and Griffin): the panics of 1873, 1884, 1893 and 1907 grew largely out of reserve pyramiding and excessive deposit creation by reserve-city banks. Supported Little disputed

Contested by Calomiris & Gorton 1991

Austrian reading: the 1873-79 'great depression' is a myth. Real output grew strongly and the money supply rose about 2.7% a year, so only prices fell. Supported Strongly disputed

Contested by Calomiris & Gorton 1991 (panic dating at the cycle peak); Friedman & Schwartz 1963 (not open)

Opposing (Gorton) reading: dating panics by New York Clearing House loan-certificate issues, 1873, 1893 and 1907 were the severe panics. In 1884 and 1890, certificates alone forestalled runs. Supported Disputed

Contested by Rothbard 2002