An Atlas of Money · All entries

Panic of 1893

Credit & ledger · 1893 – 1897 · New York City (Wall Street district)

Attested

Open on the map

In June 1893 distrust of fractional-reserve banks caused massive runs and failures nationwide. Many banks, especially in the West and South, were allowed to suspend.

Role of the state Private, under state licence or control

Whose debt A claim on an issuer

Panic on the New York Stock Exchange, 5 May 1893; Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper
Panic on the New York Stock Exchange, 5 May 1893; Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper — Unknown author Unknown author, Public domain

Eastern suspension began with New York City (Rothbard p. 169); hence the NYC anchor. Calomiris & Gorton date the panic June-August 1893, after an April 1893 cycle peak. Rothbard: money supply fell 6.3% June 1892 to June 1893, and deposits traded at a discount to currency in August. Rothbard also blames branch-banking prohibitions for hobbling clearing (p. 143), which partly overlaps with Calomiris & Gorton. The two readings agree that reserve pyramiding mattered. They differ on the remedy: branching and coinsurance (Canada as a counterexample) versus 100%-reserve hard money.

Claims and evidence

In June 1893 distrust of fractional-reserve banks caused massive runs and failures nationwide. Many banks, especially in the West and South, were allowed to suspend. Attested

Austrian reading: the gold standard was shaky because the Treasury resumed specie without contracting paper notes, and confidence gave way under silver agitation. Supported Disputed

Contested by Calomiris & Gorton 1991

Opposing (institutional) reading: panics were not inherent in banking but tied to a particular structure, unit banking with reserve pyramiding, under which spatially separated banks could not insure one another. Supported Disputed

Contested by Rothbard 2002