An Atlas of Money · All entries

Second Bank of the United States (1816-36) and Jackson's Bank War

Credit & ledger · 1816 – 1836 · Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

Attested

Open on the map

The Second Bank, chartered in 1816 on the model of the First, was a private corporation with one-fifth federal ownership. It was to issue a national paper currency, buy public debt and hold Treasury deposits.

Role of the state Private, under state licence or control

Whose debt A claim on an issuer

'General Jackson Slaying the Many Headed Monster': lithograph satire of the Bank War, H. R. Robinson, 1836
'General Jackson Slaying the Many Headed Monster': lithograph satire of the Bank War, H. R. Robinson, 1836 — N.Y. : Printed & publd. by H.R. Robinson, 1833, Public domain

Fed History stresses Jackson's political and states'-rights motives and the Bank's stabilizing role instead. Griffin relies on Remini and Biddle's correspondence. Fed History also notes Biddle's partisan conduct, so the two readings largely agree on the 1833-34 contraction. Griffin's motive attribution is graded III. Place: removal was an executive (Washington) act; the Bank itself stayed in Philadelphia. Biddle's bank continued under a Pennsylvania charter as the United States Bank of Pennsylvania; it suspended in October 1839 and closed about 1841 (Rothbard p. 101). Rothbard (p. 93) gives the same sequence: Biddle filed early, Congress passed recharter, Jackson vetoed, override failed. Rothbard also argues that its purpose was to support the state banks' inflation (Rothbard 2002, p. 83); that is an interpretation, graded II. Rothbard argues the opposite: central banks underwrote rather than restrained state-bank inflation (Rothbard 2002, p. 75).

Claims and evidence

The Second Bank, chartered in 1816 on the model of the First, was a private corporation with one-fifth federal ownership. It was to issue a national paper currency, buy public debt and hold Treasury deposits. Attested

The early recharter bill passed Congress in 1832 but could not overcome Jackson's veto. Attested

In 1833 Jackson removed Treasury deposits from the Bank to state 'pet banks' (7 at first, 91 by end-1836). The federal charter lapsed in 1836. Attested

Austrian reading: the Jacksonians were Currency-School hard-money men, not 'ignorant bumpkins'. Abolishing the central bank was their first step toward ending fractional-reserve banking. Supported Strongly disputed

Contested by Hill (Federal Reserve History) n.d.

Sound-money (Griffin) reading: Biddle deliberately contracted the money supply in 1833-34 to provoke a panic and force recharter. Weak lead Little disputed

Central-bank-history reading: under Biddle the Bank contributed to stability and growth and restrained state-bank note issue by pressing for specie redemption. Supported Strongly disputed

Contested by Rothbard 2002