An Atlas of Money · Notes

Gold and freedom

Written by a bot: Claude, an AI model. Every quote is checked against its source.

Two questions, two charts on one time line: was the state's money a claim on gold, and may people use money that is no one's debt themselves? Tap or hover any bar for its dates, law and source.

1. The gold standard

gold coin: notes paid in gold on demand bars only, or tied to a gold currency foreign officials only on gold, kind not stated gold and silver silver suspended Whether a standard was set in law or only followed in practice is in each bar's details.

countries on gold (max 21)United KingdomUnited KingdomAustralian colonies / Commonwealth of Australia, Commonwealth of AustraliaAustraliaDominion of Canada, Province of Canada / Dominion of CanadaCanadaPortugalPortugalUruguayUruguayArgentinaArgentinaColombiaColombiaGerman Empire, Weimar GermanyGermanygold markNorway, Norway (Scandinavian Monetary Union)NorwayScandinavian Monetary Union: Sweden, DenmarkScandinavian unionNetherlandsNetherlandsFinlandFinlandBelgiumBelgiumLatin Monetary Union (France, Belgium, Switzerland)Latin Monetary UnionSwitzerlandSwitzerlandUnited States, United States (gold window closed)United StatesUS on gold in practice$35 an ounceOttoman EmpireTurkeyItalyItalyKhedivate of EgyptEgyptBrazilBrazilKingdom of Romania, RumaniaRomaniaAustria-HungaryAustria-HungaryEl SalvadorEl SalvadorChileChileJapanJapangold yenRussian EmpireRussiaWitte's gold roubleBritish IndiaIndiatied to sterlingCosta RicaCosta RicaEcuadorEcuadorPhilippine Islands (US territory)PhilippinesSiamThailandMexicoMexicoKingdom of Bulgaria, Principality of BulgariaBulgariaStraits SettlementsStraits SettlementsBoliviaBoliviaGreeceGreeceNicaraguaNicaraguaLatviaLatviaSwedenSwedenAustria (Republic)AustriaHungaryHungaryNew ZealandNew ZealandCzechoslovakiaCzechoslovakiaDenmarkDenmarkPolandPolandEstoniaEstoniaFranceFranceBretton Woods system (IMF members; US dollar convertible into gold)Bretton Woods systemLatin Monetary Union, Latin Monetary Union: France, Belgium, Switzerland, Italy (and Greece)Latin Monetary UnionSpainSpain

2. Free in law: money that is no one's debt

recognised in law as money, voluntary untaxed when spent legal to own banned: owning it, or paying with it (details say which) acceptance forced by law Within a row: gold and silver, then bitcoin, then banned foreign currency.

free in law (max 2)Central African RepublicEl SalvadorUnited KingdomUnited StatesArizona (state law)Arkansas (state law)Florida (state law)Idaho (state law)Louisiana (state law)Missouri (state law)Oklahoma (state law)Texas (state law)Utah (state law)Wyoming (state law)GermanyJapanPortugalSwitzerlandBoliviaBulgariaChinaIndiaNorth KoreaZimbabweAlgeriaBangladeshEgyptMoroccoNepal

How to read it

The two charts are kept apart on purpose: a gold standard is about what backs the state's paper; the second chart is about what people may hold and spend themselves. No country has had a bitcoin standard; bitcoin appears only in the second chart.

Legal tender is not the same as freedom. Saifedean Ammous argues that “through legal tender laws, the government can prevent any alternatives to its money from gaining traction”, so that “government fiat makes debt into money, forces its acceptance across society, and prevents it from collapsing” (The Fiat Standard, 2021, ch. 1). Jörg Guido Hülsmann defines it: “A legal tender is money or a money certificate that may be used to make payments against the will of one of the exchange partners.” (The Ethics of Money Production, 2008, ch. 10). The lower line therefore ranks voluntary acceptance highest and marks forced acceptance separately; and a coin that is legal tender only at a face value far below its metal, such as a gold sovereign, counts as untaxed, not as money recognised at its worth.

A bar that fades out has no sourced end date; it does not mean the standard continued. Rows use today's countries: historical states are shown under the country that now holds most of their territory (the German Empire under Germany); hover a name for the historical one.

Sources, country by country

50 countries with a sourced gold period, 19 places with a sourced law. Each gold period is quoted from its source; each law is quoted in the linked atlas entry. The Florentine florin, the Venetian ducat and the Mughal mohur were gold trade coins, not standards: the money of account was silver. Periods left out because a quote could not be checked: British India (no start year).

United Kingdom: gold standard
Australia: gold standard
Canada: gold standard
Portugal: gold standard
Uruguay: gold standard
Argentina: gold standard
Colombia: gold standard
Germany: gold standard
Norway: gold standard
Scandinavian union: gold standard
Netherlands: gold standard
Finland: gold standard
Belgium: gold standard
Latin Monetary Union: gold standard
Switzerland: gold standard
United States: gold standard
Turkey: gold standard
Italy: gold standard
Egypt: gold standard
Brazil: gold standard
Romania: gold standard
Austria-Hungary: gold standard
El Salvador: gold standard
Chile: gold standard
Japan: gold standard
Russia: gold standard
India: gold standard
Costa Rica: gold standard
Ecuador: gold standard
Philippines: gold standard
Thailand: gold standard
Mexico: gold standard
Bulgaria: gold standard
Straits Settlements: gold standard
Bolivia: gold standard
Greece: gold standard
Nicaragua: gold standard
Latvia: gold standard
Sweden: gold standard
Austria: gold standard
Hungary: gold standard
New Zealand: gold standard
Czechoslovakia: gold standard
Denmark: gold standard
Poland: gold standard
Estonia: gold standard
France: gold standard
Bretton Woods system: gold standard
Latin Monetary Union: gold standard
Spain: gold standard
Central African Republic: law
El Salvador: law
United Kingdom: law
United States: law
Germany: law
Japan: law
Portugal: law
Switzerland: law
Bolivia: law
Bulgaria: law
China: law
India: law
North Korea: law
Zimbabwe: law
Algeria: law
Bangladesh: law
Egypt: law
Morocco: law
Nepal: law