An Atlas of Money · Notes · 16 November 2026
Testing the debate: what is money?
1. “The very first forms of money … ancient Mesopotamia, clay tablets”
Pavlina Tcherneva · 0:17:31
the very first forms of money that were invented, ancient Mesopotamia, clay tablets, not precious gold, not precious metal. Throughout most of the history of time, money has not been precious.
Refuted
- Worked gold predates the tablets by over a thousand years: about 3,000 gold objects at Varna, about 4600–4400 BC. Varna gold and spondylus
- Salt boiled into cakes at Solnitsata from about 4700 BC. Solnitsata salt production
- First Uruk tablets: about 3300 BC. Uruk accounting tablets
- The tablets were temple accounts; Englund finds “no clear evidence in the archaic texts of the use of weights, nor any evidence that silver was in any way used.” Uruk accounting tablets
- Clay tokens (from about 8000 BC) were counters for goods. Clay tokens and bullae
- Mesopotamian money in use: weighed silver and barley, Ur III (2112–2004 BC) and Kanesh (1925–1710 BC). Ur III · Kanesh
- Crux: how did money begin?
2. “Money is debt. Anyone can create money”
Pavlina Tcherneva, citing Hyman Minsky · 0:18:44
Money is debt. Anyone can create money. The point is to get it accepted.
Reply: Saifedean Ammous · 0:24:17
You can use debt as money. You can also use mugs as money.
A definition: not testable
- Atlas count by whose debt the money is: 191 entries no one's debt (gold, silver, salt, cattle, cowries, iron, bitcoin); 73 claims on an issuer (notes, deposits, tallies, scrip, stablecoins); 91 issued and redeemable for nothing, 58 of them hyperinflations.
- Money that is no one’s debt (map) · Claims on an issuer (map) · Redeemable for nothing (map)
- Crux: is money a debt or a good?
3. “Only economists tell the story of barter”
Pavlina Tcherneva · 0:22:11
only economists tell the story of barter, no other scientists will talk about societies bartering with each other
Refuted
- Scientists who were not economists recorded barter on the spot: the naturalist Darwin in Tierra del Fuego, 1834 (“a fair notion of barter”); the naturalist Wallace on the Kei Islands, 1857; the botanist Hooker in Sikkim, 1849 (“they barter wool, blankets, musk”); the anthropologist Malinowski in the Trobriands, 1915–18 (“This bartering, pure and simple”); the anthropologist Boas on Baffin Island, 1883–84 (“barter with the whalers of Cumberland Sound”). Fuegia · Kei · Sikkim · Trobriands · Baffin Island
- So did ancient geographers and historians: Strabo on inland Iberia and the tin islands; Herodotus on the silent trade. Iberia · Cassiterides
- Whether barter came before money is a different question: see 3b.
- Travellers recorded barter first-hand. Robertson, Hindu Kush, 1890–91: “Among the Kafirs themselves all business is done by barter.” Kafiristan
- Tristan da Cunha, 1824: “money is unknown”. Tristan da Cunha
- Barter priced in one good: cows (Kafiristan), sheep and brick tea (Mongolia). Mongolia
- Not barter: Herodotus's “silent trade” with strangers was a sale for gold. Silent trade for gold
- Barter after money failed: Russia, 1992–98. Russian barter and veksels
- Thirty more accounts, 1697–1925, from Greenland to Tierra del Fuego. Wallace, Kei Islands, 1857: “Money is unknown and valueless here”. Burnes, Hindu Kush, 1832: “These people have no money”. All 37 barter entries on the map
- One ethnographer rules barter out: Andaman gift exchange “cannot be spoken of as barter”. Andaman Islands
- No case in the atlas of a pure barter economy turning into money. Crux: how did money begin?
3b. “No society that has existed with barter but without money”
Pavlina Tcherneva · 0:22:28
the archaeological evidence does not show any society that has existed um with barter but without money
Refuted
- Archaeology can rarely show barter at all: an exchange of goods leaves no trace. The evidence is written, and it records societies with barter and no money.
- Burnes, Hindu Kush, 1832: “These people have no money, and are almost ignorant of its value. We got every thing from them by barter”. Hazara highlands
- Cadamosto, Senegal, 1455: “Having no money or coin of any kind, all their trade was carried on by way of barter”. Senegal, 1455
- Wallace, Kei Islands, 1857: “Money is unknown and valueless here”. Kei Islands
- St Kilda and North Rona, 1690s: no gold or silver, barter among themselves. St Kilda · North Rona
- Champa, 1225: money not used in trade; barter in wine, rice and food, accounts settled yearly. Champa
- Strabo: the Dalmatians “do not use money”, unlike their neighbours. Dalmatia
- Caveats: several of these used a staple good as a measure (cloth, tobacco, rice), and most traded beside money-using neighbours.
3c. “No evidence of money originating just from pure barter”
Pavlina Tcherneva · 0:22:40
we don't have any evidence of money originating just from pure barter transactions
Not testable as stated; what can be tested goes against it
- Why not testable: “pure barter” is undefined, since every known society also had gifts, credit or obligations, so any case can be called impure; and money first arose before writing, when objects do not record how they changed hands. The rival claim, that money began as credit, is untestable for prehistory for the same reasons.
- Before writing, the evidence is archaeological, and the earliest money-like objects are no one's debt: gold and Spondylus valuables at Varna (c. 4600 BC), salt cakes at Solnitsata, and in the Bronze Age copper-alloy rings, ribs and axe-blades of near-standard weight (c. 2200–1600 BC), weight-standardised gold at Dabene and balance weights from 3100 BC; most were made by peoples without states. Varna · Solnitsata · Rings, ribs and axe-blades · Dabene · Balance weights
- Mesopotamia shows money developing over five millennia, from records to silver: clay counters for grain, sheep and oil (from c. 8000 BC), sealed envelopes and the first tablets recording goods and debts (c. 3300 BC), then silver by weight as the common measure and means of payment (Ur III, c. 2100 BC; Kanesh merchants, c. 1900 BC; Hammurabi's laws). The counters count goods; the money that follows is a metal, not an IOU. Credit appears in the same records, but reckoned in silver: the loans at Kanesh and in Hammurabi's laws are claims to so many shekels, so the silver is the unit and the loans are claims to it. Clay tokens · Uruk tablets · Ur III · Kanesh · Hammurabi
- What objects cannot show is how they changed hands, by barter, gift or payment; so archaeology can neither prove nor rule out money arising from barter. Crux: how did money begin?
- But where people bartered without state money, one good repeatedly became the money, with no authority deciding it:
- Prisoner-of-war camp, 1940s (Radford, 1945): cigarettes from Red Cross parcels became the camp currency and price standard. POW cigarettes
- Germany, 1945–48: “cigarettes in post war Germany were not issued by any State and because it was illegal to use them in payments” (Bignon, 2009), yet they were the most liquid good. German cigarettes
- Mawson's hut, Antarctica, 1912: “The great medium of monetary exchange in the Hut was chocolate.” Cape Denison
- Whaleships, 1855: “Tobacco takes its place and is the currency”. Whaleship tobacco
- Soviet camps, 1950s: clothing priced in bread; tobacco prized “because of their high barter value”. Mordovian camps
- Caveat: these people already knew money. The cases show the mechanism her claim denies, a good becoming money out of barter without the state, not how money first began.
3d. “Move away from this notion that … we're transacting with something that has inherent value”
Pavlina Tcherneva · 0:22:48
I think we need to really move away from this notion that somehow we're transacting with something that has inherent value, precious metal value, and to start thinking about why societies issues IUs and credits to basically facilitate economic transactions
A preference, not a claim of fact; of its two assumptions, one is false and one partly true
- What can be checked is what it assumes: that the other side holds money to have “inherent value” (false: see Menger below), and that money is basically IOUs and credit (partly: credit is old and common, but most money in the atlas was no one's IOU).
- Credit is old and common, as she says: Old Assyrian loans; English tallies; split sticks for debts in Yunnan (Marco Polo); goods on trust for months at Ma-i (1225); Mexica loans; knotted-string debt tallies in Guiana. Assyrian loans · Tallies · Zardandan · Ma-i · Mexica · Guiana
- But many of those IOUs were private, between traders, not issued by “societies” or states.
- And most money in the atlas was no one's IOU: 297 of 437 classified entries (claims on an issuer: 98; state paper redeemable for nothing: 42). Gold dust in Minas Gerais, cowries in West Africa, salt, cattle, shells. All entries that are no one's debt
- When state IOUs failed, people turned to assets or to others' money: 58 hyperinflation episodes; dollars and USDT in Venezuela; the blue dollar in Argentina; yuan and dollars in North Korea despite the bans. Hyperinflations · Venezuela · Argentina · North Korea
- “Inherent value” is a position the market reading does not hold. Menger, 1871: “Value is therefore nothing inherent in goods, no property of them” … “Hence value does not exist outside the consciousness of men.” Gold became money because people valued it, and it was the most saleable good, not because value sits inside the metal. Menger, Principles of Economics, ch. III · Crux: how did money begin?
4. “Currency laws in 1751 and ’64 preventing the colonies from issuing their own currency”
Pavlina Tcherneva · 1:00:34
they put in place currency laws in 1751 and 64 preventing the colonies from issuing their own currency
Refuted
- The 1764 Act did not ban issuing paper; it banned making new bills “legal tender in payment of any bargains, contracts, debts, dues, or demands whatsoever”. The colonies could still issue paper; they could not force creditors to take it. Currency Act of 1764
- The 1751 Act applied to New England only.
- Stated reason: bills “have greatly depreciated in their value, by means whereof debts have been discharged with a much less value than was contracted for.”
- Penalty for a governor assenting: £1,000 and dismissal.
- So the Acts removed forced acceptance of a depreciating paper, not the colonies' money. Continental currency · Massachusetts Land Bank
4b. “That was one of the reasons for the Revolutionary War”
Pavlina Tcherneva · 1:01:06
So, we need our own currency. We don't want to be beholden to the British currency. That was one of the reasons for the Revolutionary War, to have independence.
Supported as a grievance
- Franklin to the House of Commons, 1766: respect for Parliament “greatly lessened”; among the causes, “the prohibition of making paper money among themselves”. Currency Act of 1764
- Franklin names it among the causes of lost respect, nine years before the war; the atlas has no source weighing it against the other causes.
4c. “You have to export all your stuff to England to be able to get the currency to pay your taxes”
Pavlina Tcherneva · 1:00:43
How do you get the British currency? You have to export all your stuff to England to be able to get the currency to pay your taxes.
Refuted, except that coin was scarce
- Most taxes were levied by the colonial assemblies and paid in the colonies' own paper or produce. Massachusetts, 1690: its bills “shall be accordingly accepted by the Treasurer and Receivers subordinate to him, in all public payments”. Massachusetts, 1648: grain taken for the country rate, “wheate and barly at five shillings p bushell”.
- Virginia paid levies, quit-rents and fees in tobacco warehouse notes (1748); Pennsylvania took a county tax “in bills of credit, or current money of Amer- ica” (1723); North Carolina's sheriffs took notes for tobacco, hemp, rice and deerskins “in Discharge of such Taxes” (1768).
- Parliament's few taxes (the Sugar Act 1764, the Stamp Act 1765, the Townshend duties 1767) were reckoned in sterling but “may be received and taken, according to the proportion and value of five shillings and six pence the ounce in silver”: any silver by weight, in practice Spanish dollars, not British coin.
- In 1773 Parliament let the assemblies make their notes “a legal tender to thé publick” treasurers “for the difcharge of any duties”, settling doubts left by the 1764 Act.
- What is true: coin was scarce. Virginia, 1755: “great scarcity of g'old and silver in this colony”; Franklin, 1766: “there is not gold and ſilver enough in the Colonies to pay the ſtamp duty for one year”. Balances with Britain were settled with “money, bills of Exchange, or commodities”, earned in trade with the West Indies and southern Europe as well as Britain. Currency Act of 1764
5. “The central bank cannot increase the money supply … cannot force money on the population”
Pavlina Tcherneva · 1:05:43
The central bank cannot increase the money supply. The only way money supply increases is if somebody makes a loan and that creates a deposit. The central bank cannot force money on the population.
Refuted
- Asked about withdrawals: “There's enough cash in the financial system. And there's an infinite amount of cash at the Federal Reserve.” Neel Kashkari, president of the Minneapolis Fed, 60 Minutes (CBS), 22 March 2020
- Asked “Is the Fed just going to print money?”: “That's literally what Congress has told us to do. That's the authority that they've given us, to print money and provide liquidity into the financial system. And that's how we do it. We create it electronically.”
- Asked whether there is “no end to your ability” to flood the system with money: “There is no end to our ability to do that.”
- Increase the money supply. Bank of England: “The central bank can also affect the amount of money directly through purchasing assets or ‘quantitative easing’” and “QE boosts broad money without directly leading to, or requiring, an increase in lending.” (McLeay, Radia and Thomas, “Money creation in the modern economy”, 2014)
- Federal Reserve, 23 March 2020: it “will continue to purchase Treasury securities and agency mortgage-backed securities in the amounts needed”. (FOMC statement)
- US M2: $15.49 trillion (Feb 2020) → $19.64 trillion (Feb 2021), +26.8% in twelve months, the fastest since the series began in 1959. (Fed H.6, seasonally adjusted; pandemic payments and emergency loans also contributed)
- Euro-area M2: +11.4%, Feb 2020 → Feb 2021. (ECB)
- Force money on the population. Yuan: paper the sole legal tender. Yuan paper money
- Siam, 1865: cowries abolished by decree, lead tokens issued. Siam lead tokens
- Colonial Brazil: merchants ordered to accept sugar. Brazil sugar decree
- United States, 1933: citizens ordered to surrender gold. Executive Order 6102
- North Korea, 2009: savings confiscated. North Korea 2009
- India 2016, Nigeria 2023: main notes stripped of legal tender. India · Nigeria
- Central African Republic, 2022: traders required to accept bitcoin. CAR bitcoin
- Every money issued or imposed by a state (map)
6. “We have never had a system where society spontaneously chose a precious metal”
Pavlina Tcherneva (identified from context) · 1:19:42
We have never had a system where society spontaneously chose a precious metal.
Refuted
- 21 atlas entries, on five continents and in 17 present-day countries, including the islands of Gotland, Sumatra and Madagascar, from about 1925 BC to today: gold or silver used as money or savings by weight, with no state issuing it. Asia: Kanesh · hacksilver in the Levant · nishka gold, India · Sogdian silver · Angkor · Sumatra · Indian household gold. Europe: the Aegean · inland Iberia · beyond Rome's frontier · Viking-age silver · Gotland. Africa: Saharan gold for salt · the Zambezi · Madagascar · the silent trade. South America: the Muisca · Minas Gerais. North America: gold quills at Tlatelolco · California · the Klondike.
- Minas Gerais: “no other money … than gold dust” (Antonil, 1711). Minas Gerais
- Zambezi, 1590s: “a weight of gold called a tanga” (João dos Santos). Zambezi
- Gold dust before any mint: Klondike · California · Sumatra
- Weighed silver: Viking Age · Gotland · Madagascar · Sogdiana · beyond Rome’s frontier
- Weighed silver in the ancient Near East and Aegean: Kanesh · hacksilver hoards · the Aegean before coinage · Abraham weighs out 400 shekels
- Gold by weight or in unstamped pieces: gold dust in quills (Tlatelolco) · Muisca gold tejuelos · Vedic nishka · Angkor
- Gold traded for salt and goods: Saharan salt for gold · silent trade for gold
- Gold held as savings: Indian household gold
7. “Under the gold standard, governments fought until they ran out of gold”
Saifedean Ammous · 1:32:06
Under the gold standard, governments fought until they ran out of gold. Under fiat money, they fight until the money in the hands of all their people runs out of value.
Partly supported
- Battle deaths, World War I (1914–18): 8,578,031. World War II (1939–45): 16,634,907. (Correlates of War, Inter-State War Data v4.0)
- All 38 interstate wars that began 1816–1913 combined: 1,733,370 battle deaths. Largest single wars: Paraguay (López) war 1864–70, 310,000; Second Russo-Turkish 1877–78, 285,000; Crimean 1853–56, 264,200; Franco-Prussian 1870–71, 204,313. (Correlates of War, Inter-State War Data v4.0)
- World War I alone: about five times the battle deaths of all interstate wars in the century before it.
- Counts are battle deaths in wars between states only: civilian deaths and civil wars (Taiping, US Civil War) are not included.
- Britain, August 1915: the Treasury asked the public to pay in gold and use notes. Treasury appeal
- Paper issued to pay for wars: Assignats · Continental · Greenbacks
8. “After 1971 the money supply started increasing a lot more rapidly”
Saifedean Ammous · 2:07:40
there's a very very serious change that happened in the pricing and the supply after 1971. Money supply started increasing a lot more rapidly. Prices started increasing a lot more rapidly.
Prices: supported. US M2: refuted, except the 1970s
- US consumer prices, average yearly rise: 2.8% in 1959–71; 3.9% in 1971–2026; 8.5% in 1971–81. (BLS CPI-U, August to August)
- US price level: ×4.1 in the 58 years 1913–71; ×8.2 in the 55 years 1971–2026. (BLS CPI-U)
- Years in which US prices fell: 15 in 1914–71; 1 in 1972–2026. (BLS CPI-U)
- Caution: official price indices such as the BLS CPI apply hedonic quality adjustments and substitution, and leave some rising costs out; they are not a reliable measure of a currency’s loss. The atlas measures debasement by money supply (M2 below).
- An independent measure: the Chapwood Index “reports the unadjusted actual cost and price fluctuation of the top 150 items on which Americans spend their after-tax dollars in the 50 largest cities”. Its method: “We take the precise price for the same item quarter by quarter and calculate the increase or decrease.” Calendar 2025: prices up 9.3% to 14.5% by city (median 10.9%; New York 11.3%), against 2.7% on the official CPI (BLS CPI-U, Dec 2024 to Dec 2025). It publishes city results, not the item prices behind them.
- US M2, average yearly growth: 7.2% in 1959–71; 6.6% in 1971–2026; 9.5% in 1971–81; 6.0% in 1981–2026. (Fed H.6, seasonally adjusted; the series begins in 1959)
- Before 1959, Friedman and Schwartz's M2 (currency and commercial-bank deposits, a narrower measure; today's M2 was 1.4 times theirs in 1959–60): 1.3% a year in 1867–79, from the greenbacks to the return to gold; 7.0% in 1879–1913, the classical gold standard; 3.5% in 1914–33; 7.6% in 1933–59. (Friedman and Schwartz, Monetary Statistics of the United States, 1970, Table 1)
- So money in the broad sense grew about as fast under the gold standard (7.0% a year, 1879–1913) as after 1971 (6.6%).
- Where the gold-standard growth came from: the base (currency and bank reserves) grew 4.5% a year and supplied about two-thirds of M2's growth; the rest came from people holding more of their money in banks and banks keeping less in reserve. Within the base, gold supplied 64% of the rise, silver bought under the 1878 and 1890 acts 18%, national bank notes 16%. The monetary gold stock itself grew 6.5% a year. (Data from Cagan, Determinants and Effects of Changes in the Stock of Money, 1875–1960, NBER 1965, Table F-5, and Friedman and Schwartz, Table 20; the split by period is the atlas's, using Cagan's own formula.)
- So growth under gold rested mainly on more gold, mined and imported, with silver and bank credit on top. Unlike paper since 1971, the gold had to be found.
- US M2: $685 billion (Aug 1971) → $23.3 trillion (Aug 2026), ×34. (Fed H.6)
- The US had ended gold convertibility for its own citizens in 1933; 1971 ended it for foreign governments. Executive Order 6102
- Gold window closed (1971) · Bretton Woods (1944)
- See also: WTF Happened in 1971? (charts compiled by others)