An Atlas of Money · All entries
Ming horse markets: horses priced in silk and cloth
Supported Little disputed
Open on the mapUnder Yongle, Ming opened horse markets at Kaiyuan and Guangning, pricing a top horse at eight bolts of silk or twelve of cloth. The Datong market (1438) banned weapons, copper and iron. Esen's anger at cut horse prices led to the Tumu disaster of 1449, and the 1551 Xuanfu–Datong markets were opened, closed and reopened in 1570.
Private, under state licence or control
No one's debt
Claims and evidence
Under Yongle, Ming opened horse markets at Kaiyuan and Guangning, pricing a top horse at eight bolts of silk or twelve of cloth. The Datong market (1438) banned weapons, copper and iron. Esen's anger at cut horse prices led to the Tumu disaster of 1449, and the 1551 Xuanfu–Datong markets were opened, closed and reopened in 1570. Supported Little disputed
“永樂間,設馬市三:一在開原南關,以待海西;一在開原城東五里,一在廣寧,皆以待朵顏三衛。定直四等:上直絹八疋,布十二,次半之,下二等各以一遞減。”In the Yongle era three horse markets were set up: one at the south gate of Kaiyuan for the Haixi [Jurchens]; one five li east of Kaiyuan and one at Guangning, both for the three Doyan guards. Prices were set in four grades: the top grade worth eight bolts of silk or twelve of cloth, the next half that, and the two lower grades each reduced by one.
Zhang Tingyu et al., Mingshi (1739), ch. 81 'Shihuo 5' (incl. maritime trade offices and horse markets); Chinese text (Wikisource), Mingshi 81“巡撫盧睿請令軍民平價市駝馬,達官指揮李原等通譯語,禁市兵器、銅鐵。”Grand coordinator Lu Rui asked that soldiers and people be allowed to buy camels and horses at fair prices, with the Mongol-born commander Li Yuan and others interpreting, and that the sale of weapons, copper and iron be banned.
Zhang Tingyu et al., Mingshi (1739), ch. 81 'Shihuo 5' (incl. maritime trade offices and horse markets); Chinese text (Wikisource), Mingshi 81, Datong market from Zhengtong 3 (1438)“時也先貢馬互市,中官王振裁其馬價,也先大舉入寇,遂致土木之變。”At that time Esen brought horses as tribute and for trade; the eunuch Wang Zhen cut the price of his horses, Esen invaded in force, and this led to the Tumu disaster.
Zhang Tingyu et al., Mingshi (1739), ch. 81 'Shihuo 5' (incl. maritime trade offices and horse markets); Chinese text (Wikisource), Mingshi 81, Zhengtong era“明年罷大同馬市,宣府猶未絕,抄掠不已,乃並絕之。”The next year the Datong horse market was closed; the Xuanfu one was not yet ended, but raiding continued, so both were ended.
Zhang Tingyu et al., Mingshi (1739), ch. 81 'Shihuo 5' (incl. maritime trade offices and horse markets); Chinese text (Wikisource), Mingshi 81, 1552