An Atlas of Money · All entries
Weighed gold and silver in the Aegean before coinage
Supported Disputed
Open on the mapBefore coins, gold and silver were weighed and used to store and pay value in the Aegean, from Mycenaean Pylos to Archaic Ephesus. Whether hoards of cut gold and silver were money or craft stock is still being tested.
No state involved
No one's debt
Claims and evidence
Historians should drop the terms pre-money and proto-money and judge weighed metal by the functions of money: measure of value, store of value and means of payment. Supported Little disputed
- Zurbach, Metal money before coinage in the Aegean, ca. 1400–600 BC (2021), pp. 318, 326 (after Andreau 2001)
Tablet PY Jo 438 from Pylos records gold contributions from officials (one about 1 kg, nine of about 250 g); weighed gold may have served as money among the rich while the palace accounted in kind, though the values show no standardisation and Homer gives no gold payments. Weak lead Disputed
Contested by Finley (1957) and Polanyi (1960), as relayed by Zurbach: the Mycenaean palace economy worked in a completely non-monetary way
- Zurbach (2021), pp. 319–322
The Eretria hoard (late 8th c. BC) and the Khaniale Tekke tomb near Knossos (mid-9th c. BC) hold cut gold, bars and dumps that may be money by weight (Hackgold) or a goldsmith's stock; the test is whether the dumps follow a weight unit. Supported Disputed
Contested by Hutchinson & Boardman (1954); Boardman (1967): the tomb of a Levantine goldsmith, the dumps his working material
- Zurbach (2021), p. 322
Weighed silver was money in the Aegean from about 650 BC, on the evidence of Solon's valuations, the Artemision account at Ephesus (gold and silver weighed in minas) and late 6th-c. Hacksilber hoards; early Archaic hoards like the Levantine ones are missing. Supported Disputed
Contested by Davis (2012), as relayed by Zurbach: against reading Solon as valuations in silver; a later chronology
- Zurbach (2021), pp. 322–325