An Atlas of Money · All entries
Crux: how did money begin?
Strongly disputed
Open on the mapMarket reading: money emerges from barter as the most saleable commodity (Menger 1892; Mises 1912, regression theorem). State and credit reading: money begins as debt records and state-imposed units (Knapp 1905; Innes 1913; Graeber 2011). Linked entries are where the two readings meet evidence. Collectibles reading: money began as stores of wealth before trade (Szabo 2002).
Claims and evidence
Market origin: the most saleable commodity becomes money without the state. Supported Strongly disputed
Contested by Knapp (1905), Innes (1913), Graeber (2011)
“Money has not been generated by law. In its origin it is a social, and not a state-Imstitution. Sanction by the authority of the state is a notion alien to it.”
Menger, 'On the Origin of Money', Economic Journal 2 (1892), Economic Journal 2, p. 255“Whenever a direct exchange seemed out of the question, each of the parties to a transaction would naturally endeavour to exchange his superfluous commodities, not merely for more marketable commodities in general, but for the most market¬ able commodities; and among these again he would naturally prefer whichever particular commodity was the most marketable of all.”
Mises, Theory of Money and Credit (1912), 1953 ed. p. 31“Men have been led, with increasing knowledge of their individual interests, each by his own economic interests, without convention, without legal compulsion, nay, even without any regard to the common interest, to exchange goods destined for exchange (their ‘‘ wares’’) for other goods equally destined for exchange, but more saleable.”
Menger, 'On the Origin of Money', Economic Journal 2 (1892), Economic Journal 2, p. 248“It is not the State, but the common practice of all those who have dealings in the market, that creates money.”
Mises, Theory of Money and Credit (1912), 1953 ed. p. 77“Economic theory and rationality can not only give a hint but also a logical reasoning why credit must be the last function in the chain”
Svensson, 'Money and Coinage: Origins, Functions, and Institutions', in Economic Perspectives on Monetary History (2026), ch. 2“Written sources cannot determine which theory is correct, as money existed much earlier than the written language”
Svensson, 'Money and Coinage: Origins, Functions, and Institutions', in Economic Perspectives on Monetary History (2026), ch. 2
Credit and state origin: money is a unit of account for debts, created by authority. Supported Strongly disputed
Contested by Menger (1892), Mises (1912), Hoppe (1994), Svensson (2026)
“They acquire their value in this way. The government by law obliges certain selected persons to become its debtors. It declares that so-and-so, who imports goods from abroad, shall owe the government so much on all that he imports, or that so-and-so, who owns land, shall owe to the government so much per acre.”
Innes, 'What is Money?', Banking Law Journal 30 (1913), Banking Law Journal 30(5), p. 398“Money is a creature of law. A theory of money must therefore deal with legal history.”
Knapp, The State Theory of Money (1905), 1924 transl., ch. I §1, p. 1“Credit is the purchasing power so often mentioned in economic works as being one of the principal attributes of money, and, as I shall try to show, credit and credit alone is money. Credit and not gold or silver is the one property which all men seek, the acquisition of which is the aim and object of all commerce.”
Innes, 'What is Money?', Banking Law Journal 30 (1913), Banking Law Journal 30(5), p. 392“Such pieces are called Chartal means of payment, or money. The validity is independent of the contents of the pieces. Law proceeds from the State ; money is accordingly a State institution.”
Knapp, The State Theory of Money (1905), 1924 transl., analytical table of contents, summary of ch. I §2“money is a creature of the state. The state defines money as that which it accepts at public pay offices (mainly, in payment of taxes).”
Wray, 'Modern Money', Levy Economics Institute WP 252 (1998)“Chartalism, on the other hand, posits that money (broadly speaking) is a unit of account, designated by a public authority for the codification of social debt obligations.”
Tcherneva, 'The Nature, Origins, and Role of Money', CFEPS WP 46 (2005)- Doha Debates, 'What Is Money? Debating MMTers' (2026): Tcherneva and Hickel vs. Ammous
Collectibles reading (Szabo, 2002): money began as durable, hard-to-forge collectibles whose first use was storing and moving wealth (inheritance, bride price, tribute, blood money), before large-scale trade; neither barter-first nor debt-first. A secondary essay; Szabo calls parts of his scenario hypothetical. Weak lead Disputed
Contested by Malinowski (1922): kula valuables were ceremonial gifts, not money (entry kula); Holmes (1883) and Morgan (1851): wampum's use as money before Europeans cannot be shown (entry wampum)
“The primary and ultimate evolutionary function of collectibles was as a medium for storing and transferring wealth.”
Szabo, N., 'Shelling Out: The Origins of Money' (2002), Satoshi Nakamoto Institute“Primitive money existed long before large scale trade networks”
Szabo, N., 'Shelling Out: The Origins of Money' (2002), Satoshi Nakamoto Institute“The scenario illustrated by the accompanying figure is hypothetical”
Szabo, N., 'Shelling Out: The Origins of Money' (2002), Satoshi Nakamoto Institute
Long-stay ethnographies in the atlas (32 cases, Amazonia to the Arctic and the Pacific) find that inside bands and villages goods moved mostly by sharing, redistribution and gifts that had to be returned, with debts remembered and paid later; bargained barter was recorded mainly with other groups and traders, and money and interest-bearing debt inside the community appear in ranked, settled societies. Supported Little disputed
“if only one seal is caught, the whole of the meat must be distributed, otherwise some of the people would go hungry.”
Jenness, D., The Life of the Copper Eskimos (Report of the Canadian Arctic Expedition 1913-18, vol. XII, 1922), Social organization: Property, Property, p. 90“between equals a person who gives a present always expects that he will receive something of equal value in exchange.”
Radcliffe-Brown, A. R., The Andaman Islanders (1922), ch. I, ch. I“Sie erfolgt bisweilen erst Monate nachher, aber mit größter Gewissenhaftigkeit.”It [payment in trade goods of corresponding value] sometimes takes place only months afterwards, but with the greatest conscientiousness.
Th. Koch-Grünberg, Zwei Jahre unter den Indianern, vol. 1 (1909), vol. 1, p. 130“This bartering, pure and simple, takes place mainly between the industrial communities of the interior”
Malinowski, B., Argonauts of the Western Pacific (1922), ch. VI, list of gifts, class 7, ch. VI, div. VI, class 7 (gimwali between villages)“although they are keen bargainers, often spending two or three hours in debating the price to be given, they appreciated the fairness with which they were treated.”
G. C. Musters, At Home with the Patagonians (1871), Santa Cruz trading station (Mr Clarke's tariff)“The rate of interest is cent, per cent, without regard to time. A man borrows, aru, and the owner lends, tatce ; a debt, pug, is thus established.”
Codrington, R. H., The Melanesians: studies in their anthropology and folk-lore (1891), ch. XVI Arts of life: Money, ch. XVI, p. 326 (Banks Islands)
Rosenswig (2025) argues that barter appeared only in societies with existing monetary systems, when formal currency was scarce or between strangers, and never came before money. Attested Strongly disputed
Contested by Atlas entries that record barter where no money was in use: Senegal 1455 (ea-cayor-barter), St Kilda (bt-st-kilda), North Rona (bt-north-rona), the Hazara highlands (bt-hazara), the Kei Islands (bt-kei) and Champa (ea-champa).
“Instead, barter appeared only in societies with existing monetary systems when formal currency was scarce or between strangers for one-off exchanges — not as the foundation of whole economies.”
University at Albany News, 'Study: Ancient Tally Sticks Challenge Myths About Money' (25 Sept 2025), on Rosenswig (2025)“The historical record shows that barter doesn't precede the creation of financial money,”
University at Albany News, 'Study: Ancient Tally Sticks Challenge Myths About Money' (25 Sept 2025), on Rosenswig (2025)
Connections
- Clay tokens and bullae
- Uruk accounting tablets
- Solnitsata salt production
- Varna gold and spondylus
- Kanesh: weighed silver in Old Assyrian trade
- Bronze Age rings, ribs and axe-blades
- Kissi pennies
- Rai stones
- Kula ring
- Quipu accounting
- Spondylus (mullu) in the Andes
- Exchequer tally sticks
- The Cantillon effect: who gains from new money
- Bitcoin genesis block
- The balance weight spreads west from Egypt and Mesopotamia
- Weighed gold and silver in the Aegean before coinage
- Coin gap on the Upper Thracian plain
- Cigarettes in a WWII POW camp
- Cigarette money in post-war Germany
- Prison commodity money: ramen
- Somali shilling without a state
- Iraqi 'Swiss dinar' in Kurdistan
- Hawala
- Bitcoin's first priced purchase
- California gold dust and private mints
- Klondike gold dust
- Scottish free banking
- British commercial copper tokens
- US Depression scrip
- Santa Cruz red-feather money
- Banks Islands shell money
- Langalanga shell-disc money
- New Hebrides mat money
- Tolai shell money (tambu)
- Palauan bead money (udoud)
- Rossel Island shell money
- Massim axe blades as currency
- Motu shell-disc strings
- Highland New Guinea shell valuables
- Baruya salt money
- Iron hoes as bridewealth currency
- Cattle and goats as blood-money (Nandi)
- The goat as unit of value (Kikuyu)
- Chukchi trade standards: tobacco and tea
- Bering Strait skin unit of value
- Iceland: cloth and cow-values as money
- Gotland's weighed silver economy
- Early Irish sét and cumal
- Kwakwaka'wakw blankets and coppers
- Dentalium shell money
- Clamshell disc-bead money (Pomo and southern California)
- Glass beads on the Lower Columbia
- Horses as standard of value on the Plains
- Buffalo robes as money
- Quiripa shell-bead currency
- Silent trade for gold
- Argentine trueque and the crédito
- Maasai cattle as blood-money and bridewealth
- Fijian tabua (whale teeth)
- Samoan fine mats ('ie toga)
- English seventeenth-century trade tokens
- 1837 'shinplasters' (private small notes)
- US Civil War tokens
- Coal-company scrip (Stearns Coal and Lumber, Big South Fork)
- Tobacco as currency in colonial Virginia
- Rum as currency in early New South Wales
- Kent cigarettes as money in Ceausescu's Romania
- London goldsmiths' notes
- US free-bank and 'wildcat' notes
- Swedish enskilda bank notes
- Canadian chartered-bank notes
- Hong Kong commercial note-issuing banks
- e-gold
- Liberty Dollar (NORFED)
- DigiCash ecash (CyberBucks trial, Mark Twain Bank)
- Linden dollars (Second Life)
- Online-game gold and real-money trading ('gold farming', incl. WoW gold)
- Airtime transfers as informal money
- M-Pesa
- Tether (USDT) stablecoin
- Bitcoin's first exchange rate (New Liberty Standard)
- WIR (Wirtschaftsring) credit currency
- LETS 'green dollars' (Comox Valley)
- Ithaca HOURS
- BerkShares
- Woergl stamp scrip ('Arbeitswertscheine')
- Chiemgauer regional currency
- Banco Palmas and the palma social currency
- Deutsche Mark, then euro, in Kosovo
- Deutsche Mark, then euro, in Montenegro
- Spontaneous US dollar and rand use in Zimbabwe
- Dollarised cash economy in Lebanon (after 2019 banking collapse)
- Roman-law irregular deposit (depositum irregulare)
- Bitcoin self-custody (hardware wallets)
- Clearinghouse loan certificates (1857-1914)
- Cuba: the peso, the end of the CUC and state dollarisation
- Cuba: the informal dollar rate, private dollars and crypto
- North Korea's markets: dollars, yuan and grain
- North Korea: the 2009 confiscation and foreign-currency crackdowns
- Venezuela: de facto dollarisation, USDT and three bolívar redenominations
- Iran: the rial under sanctions, gold coins, dollars and Bitcoin mining
- Afghanistan after 2021: afghani, dollars and hawala
- Syria: the pound's collapse and the Turkish lira in the north-west
- Myanmar after the 2021 coup: fixed kyat rate, parallel market and the NUG digital kyat
- Argentina: the blue dollar under the cepo
- East Germany: Intershops and Forum cheques
- Russian-American Company skin and parchment scrip ('leather money')
- Viking-Age weighed silver: balance weights at Birka and Hedeby, and ring money
- Santafé de Bogotá mint (Casa de Moneda, 1620)
- Kafiristan: the cow as standard of value
- Kabul's money dealers: payments without banks
- Naga hills: iron chabili, conch shells and salt
- Car Nicobar: coconuts as currency
- Palau bead money
- Northern Siberia: reindeer and squirrel skins as units of value
- Mongolia: sheep, brick tea and squirrel skins as units of account
- Kazakh steppe: horses and sheep as money
- Guiana: green stones as Carib money
- Tristan da Cunha: an island without money
- St Kilda: dues measured in barley, coin of no account
- Cape Verde: woven cloth (panos) as money
- Amazon rubber camps: aviamento credit without cash
- Asháninka salt money (Cerro de la Sal)
- Pegu: ganza, a money anyone could stamp
- Chiang Mai: salt, then gambling-house porcelain as small change
- Siam: the king ends cowrie money with lead tokens (1865)
- Angkor: rice, cloth, gold and silver
- Stung Treng: iron ingots as everyday money
- Bontoc Igorot: rice bundles (palay) as money
- Angote: iron 'shovels' as money
- Somali blood-money in camels
- Arabia: blood-money in camels
- Kordofan: cotton cloth and grain as currency
- Darfur: the sultan's iron coins and their fall
- Northern Rhodesia: calico in place of cash
- Unyamwezi: beads, cloth and wire as currency
- Brazil: sugar made money by decree
- Minas Gerais: gold dust as the only money
- Angola: libongo cloth money
- Zambezi: gold by weight, copper and pewter bars, beads and cloth
- Buganda: ivory discs (sanga) as currency
- Gabon: Fang iron bikei, and prices in ivory
- Flores: elephant tusks as store of value and bride-price
- Crux: is money a debt or a good?
- Spondylus shell rings in the Balkan Copper Age
- Kei Islands: knives, cloth and arrack for money
- Gambia: barter priced in bars of iron
- Gabon: bush trade by barter
- Angola: barter priced in the “long”
- Western Tibet: a barter fair
- Sikkim: wool and musk for rice
- Hazara highlands: “no money”
- Chiloé: tobacco above money
- Tierra del Fuego: a nail for two fish
- New Zealand, 1769: ship-side barter
- Tsaidam: goats for brick tea
- Coppermine river: copper for iron
- Shoshone: horses for a coat and knives
- Upper Yukon: a gun for its height in furs
- Labrador: pelts priced in money
- West Greenland: barter as trade and as a game
- Baffin Island: bearskins for the whalers
- Kiakhta: barter by decree
- Trobriands: gimwali, barter pure and simple
- Fiji: market barter of fish and salt
- Pitcairn: barter with passing ships
- Andaman Islands: gifts, not barter
- North-west Amazon: barter and gifts between tribes
- Sarawak: no money up-country
- Queensland: barter for axe stone
- Central Australia: ochre between tribes
- St Kilda: neither gold nor silver
- North Rona: five families, no money
- Reykjavík: the barter season
- Persians: owing money as the second disgrace
- Lusitania: everyday prices in drachmae and obols
- Inland Iberia: goods or cut silver instead of money
- Tin Islands: tin, lead and skins for pottery and salt
- Dalmatians: no money, unlike their neighbours
- Caucasian Albania: no coin, exchange by loads
- Germania: frontier tribes pick Roman coin, the interior barters
- Sri Lanka: a king judges Roman coin by its weight
- Barygaza: Roman coin exchanged at a profit
- Da Qin, seen from China: gold and silver coin
- Gangetic India: cowries in the market
- Sasu: silent trade of cattle, salt and iron for gold
- Sri Lanka: Roman gold against Persian silver
- China, 851: copper the only current coin
- China, 851: the state pays an honest bankrupt's creditors
- Champa: wine and rice, accounts settled yearly
- Langkasuka: barter at rates fixed in gold and silver
- Ma-i: goods advanced on trust for months
- Rubruck, 1254: the paper money of Cathay
- Yunnan: cowries tied to silver
- Zardandan: split tally sticks for debts
- Land of Darkness: silent barter for furs
- Gao: buying and selling with cowries
- Timbuktu: unstamped gold and cowries
- Djenné: unstamped gold and iron by weight
- Senegal, 1455: no coin, all trade by barter
- Guanahani, 1492: cotton for scraps
- Texas, c.1530: a go-between carrying shells inland
- Northern Mexico, 1535: gifts and ritual plunder
- Hochelaga, 1535: shell beads used as gold and silver
- Inca Peru: no buying or selling, by Garcilaso's account
- Cuzco, 1550s: barter in a colonial market without coin
- Brunei, 1521: Chinese copper cash
- Gujarat: a unit that is “nought but a name”
- Guiana: debt tallies of knotted string
- Trio and Wayana: present for present
- Patagones: Tehuelche barter, rations and beaten dollars
- Cape Denison, 1912: chocolate money
- Siusí (Baniwa): the chief shares out the catch, debts paid months later
- Kobéua: bought now, paid for later
- Taulipáng and Makuschí: food shared, barter on long credit
- Yekuana: the elder shares out the catch
- Coastal Guiana Arawak: lending without care for payment
- Upper Xingu: catch shared house by house, guest-gifts between tribes
- Bororo: game shared out, not traded
- Canela: valuables passed on as obligatory fees
- Lengua (Enxet): no one to have more than his neighbour
- Abipones: the cacique gives whatever is asked
- Choroti and Ashluslay: one day giving, the next receiving
- Copper Inuit: food shared by rule, other things lent, given back or bartered
- Colville and Point Barrow Inuit: fish piles shared, dance gifts repaid
- Point Barrow: bear meat divided, whalebone bought up
- Norton Sound: the Asking festival
- Todas: funeral gifts, in buffaloes and later rupees
- Buganda: cowrie prices and clan help with debts
- Ba-ila: salt baskets as currency, a chief inherits debts
- Tonga: open tables and a chief's view of money
- Arrernte: a fixed habit of giving
- Tobacco, skins and cows: the Bakwena kaross trade with the Bakalahari
- Makololo, 1853: 'familiar with barter alone'; ivory as a gift
- Viking-Age Denmark: silver paid by weight, hoards cut to øre units
- Ribe and Hedeby pennies: two managed local currencies in the 9th century
- Finnmark: Russian (Pomor) meal bartered for fish, one vog for one vog
- Sámi: coin taken by weight, silver buried, wealth in reindeer
- Finland: raha, the word for money, first meant a fur