An Atlas of Money · All entries

Tobacco, skins and cows: the Bakwena kaross trade with the Bakalahari

Commodity · 1845 – 1852 · Bakwena country (Kolobeng) and the eastern Kalahari, Botswana

Attested Disputed

Open on the map

Livingstone: the Bakalahari attach themselves to influential Tswana 'to obtain supplies of spears, knives, tobacco, and dogs, in exchange for the skins'. The Bakwena bought tobacco from eastern tribes, bought skins with it, sewed them into karosses and went south to buy heifers, 'cows being the highest form of riches known'.

Role of the state No state involved

Whose debt No one's debt

Tobacco works as an intermediate good in a chain of trades (indirect exchange), ending in cattle as the store of wealth.

Claims and evidence

Between groups under clientage: Kalahari hunters (Bakalahari) supplied skins to Tswana patrons for spears, knives, tobacco and dogs; Livingstone calls the compact 'mutually beneficial' but says other Tswana sometimes seized the skins by force. Attested Disputed

Contested by Livingstone's own report that other Tswana sometimes seized the skins by force: the Bakalahari were a subject people, so the exchange was partly tribute.

A chain of trades ending in cattle: tobacco from the east bought skins, karosses made from the skins bought heifers in the south. Cows were the top store of wealth. Attested Little disputed

Connections