An Atlas of Money · All entries

Guanahani, 1492: cotton for scraps

Commodity · 1492 – 1493 · Guanahani (San Salvador), Bahamas

Attested Little disputed

Open on the map

Columbus saw an islander give sixteen skeins of cotton for three small Portuguese coins, taken as objects, not money; the islanders gave all they had for broken crockery and glass.

Role of the state No state involved

Whose debt No one's debt

The islanders take small European coins as objects. Only Columbus, not the Taino, values the swap in money. The journal survives in Las Casas's abstract, and this part is quoted in the first person. Which island Guanahani was is disputed, so no coordinates.

Claims and evidence

Columbus saw an islander give sixteen skeins of cotton for three small Portuguese coins, taken as objects, not money; the islanders gave all they had for broken crockery and glass. Attested Little disputed

Farther on, Columbus quarrelled with islanders who would not exchange, and 'they replied that they were not accustomed to barter'; on Hispaniola he gave beads and bells unasked, and in January 1493 the Pinta got large pieces of gold 'in exchange for a needle'. Attested Little disputed

Connections