An Atlas of Money · All entries
Coastal Guiana Arawak: lending without care for payment
Supported Disputed
Open on the mapRoth's compilation quotes Hilhouse that the Arawak, though property was individual, were “perpetually borrowing and lending without the least care about payment”. Canoes were sold on long credit, and Roth was asked for a return on a gift a week later.
No state involved
A claim on an issuer
Claims and evidence
Inside the group: Hilhouse, quoted by Roth, says the Arawak have no community of goods, but property is so simple and easily got that they are perpetually borrowing and lending without the least care about payment. Supported Disputed
Contested by im Thurn (1883), on the interior Guiana tribes: 'a complete system of tit-for-tat' regulates the Indian's whole life
“They have not a community of goods, individual property being distinctly marked between them. But this property is so simple and so easily acquired that they are perpetually borrowing and lending without the least care about pay- ment (HiC, 231).”
W. E. Roth, An Introductory Study of the Arts, Crafts, and Customs of the Guiana Indians, BAE 38th Annual Report (1924), ch. XXXII, Trade and barter, ¶816, p. 632 (quoting Hilhouse)
With other groups and buyers: canoes, the dearest articles, were sold on credit 'to a ridiculous extent'; value depended on the buyer's want; and a Patamona who had given Roth a stick asked a week later for a knick-knack in return. Supported Little disputed
“In the purchase of corials and canoes, their [Arawak] most expensive arti- cles, the buyer is frequently credited to what we should call a ridicu- lous extent, especially as the means seldom exists of enforcing pay- ment (HiC, 231).”
W. E. Roth, An Introductory Study of the Arts, Crafts, and Customs of the Guiana Indians, BAE 38th Annual Report (1924), ¶820, p. 633“In trade and barter the value of an article to an Indian de- pends upon his temporary want of it and not upon its intrinsic worth (SR, II, 393).”
W. E. Roth, An Introductory Study of the Arts, Crafts, and Customs of the Guiana Indians, BAE 38th Annual Report (1924), ¶817, p. 632“About a week later, when opening my " trade," he saw some knickknack that took his fancy ; he asked me for this, reminding me of his previous present to me of the stick.”
W. E. Roth, An Introductory Study of the Arts, Crafts, and Customs of the Guiana Indians, BAE 38th Annual Report (1924), ¶818, p. 633 (Patamona village of Karikaparu)