An Atlas of Money · All entries
Fifth Lateran Council on the Montes pietatis, 1515
Attested Little disputed
Open on the mapIn 1515 the Fifth Lateran Council declared that the Montes pietatis, public pawn-lending funds, were not usurious if, beyond the capital, they charged only a moderate sum to cover staff and upkeep and made no profit. It approved founding more of them.
No state role recorded
A claim on an issuer
Claims and evidence
The council's bill on the Montes pietatis says they lend to the poor so that they are not swallowed up by usurers, and declares that a moderate charge beyond the capital, used only to pay staff and upkeep and making no profit, is not usurious. Attested Little disputed
“to assist by this kind of loan the lack of resources among the poor lest they be swallowed up by the greed of usurers”
Fifth Lateran Council, session 10 (4 May 1515), bull on the Montes pietatis, English translation (N. Tanner ed.), session 10, bull on the Montes pietatis, narrative“do not introduce any kind of evil or provide any incentive to sin if they receive, in addition to the capital, a moderate sum for their expenses and by way of compensation, provided it is intended exclusively to defray the expenses of those employed and of other things pertaining (as mentioned) to the upkeep of the organisations, and provided that no profit is made therefrom.”
Fifth Lateran Council, session 10 (4 May 1515), bull on the Montes pietatis, English translation (N. Tanner ed.), same, operative clause ('we declare and define')“It certainly should not be considered as usurious;”
Fifth Lateran Council, session 10 (4 May 1515), bull on the Montes pietatis, English translation (N. Tanner ed.), session 10, bull on the Montes pietatis
The Lateran V decree on the Montes pietatis reports the opponents' case: a charge on top of the capital is usury because 'our Lord, according to Luke the evangelist' commanded that nothing beyond the capital be expected from a loan. The decree also records their definition of usury as gain from a thing that produces nothing. Attested Little disputed
“For this reason they cannot avoid the crime of usury or injustice, that is to say a clearly defined evil, since our Lord, according to Luke the evangelist, has bound us by a clear command that we ought not to expect any addition to the capital sum when we grant a loan.”
Fifth Lateran Council, session 10 (4 May 1515), bull on the Montes pietatis (Inter multiplices), English translation as published by papalencyclicals.net (N. Tanner ed.), session 10, bull on the Montes pietatis, narrative (opponents' argument)“For, that is the real meaning of usury: when, from its use, a thing which produces nothing is applied to the acquiring of gain and profit without any work, any expense or any risk.”
Fifth Lateran Council, session 10 (4 May 1515), bull on the Montes pietatis (Inter multiplices), English translation as published by papalencyclicals.net (N. Tanner ed.), same, immediately following