An Atlas of Money · All entries
US scrip acts: wages in money, not store orders
Attested Little disputed
Open on the mapFrom the 1880s US states passed laws against paying wages in store orders and scrip. Courts first struck some down as interference with free contract (Pennsylvania, 1886), then upheld others: West Virginia's 1891 act forbidding scrip in paying miners, and Tennessee's 1899 act, upheld by the US Supreme Court in 1901, which did not ban scrip but made every coupon or store order redeemable in lawful money on demand. In the Tennessee case the orders had been taken without proof of compulsion and traded at 75 cents on the dollar, 85 after the act. A federal wage rule (1967) says scrip and tokens are not proper payment of wages.
Private, under state licence or control
A claim on an issuer
Claims and evidence
Tennessee's act of 1899 required anyone paying workers in coupons, scrip, punchouts or store orders to redeem them in lawful money on demand, in the hands of the worker or a bona fide holder. The Supreme Court affirmed it in Knoxville Iron Co. v. Harbison (1901), two justices dissenting. Attested Little disputed
“That all persons, firms, corporations and companies, using coupons, scrip, punchouts, store orders or other evidences of indebtedness to pay their or its laborers and employes, for labor or otherwise, shall, if demanded, redeem the same in the hands of such laborer, employe or bona fide holder, in lawful money of the United States”
Knoxville Iron Co. v. Harbison, 183 U.S. 13 (decided 21 Oct. 1901), slip opinion, Tennessee act of 17 March 1899, s. 1, as quoted in the opinion, pp. 3-4“Mr. Justice Brewer and Mr. Justice Peckham dissent.”
Knoxville Iron Co. v. Harbison, 183 U.S. 13 (decided 21 Oct. 1901), slip opinion, p. 7, after 'Affirmed.'
The court below found no proof of compulsion beyond the company's practice of paying wages about twenty days in arrears to those who did not take coal orders. A dealer bought the orders at seventy-five cents on the dollar before the act and eighty-five after it. Attested Little disputed
“There is no proof of any compulsion on the part of the defendant upon its operatives, except in so far as compulsion may be implied from the fact that unless defendant's operatives take their wages in coal orders they must always on each monthly pay day suffer the defendant to be in arrears about twenty days”
Knoxville Iron Co. v. Harbison, 183 U.S. 13 (decided 21 Oct. 1901), slip opinion, facts found, quoted p. 3“They had previously been selling at seventy-five cents on the dollar—that is, before the passage of chapter 11, Acts of 1899—but he instructed his agents to give eighty-five cents on the dollar, and the orders now in suit were purchased at that price.”
Knoxville Iron Co. v. Harbison, 183 U.S. 13 (decided 21 Oct. 1901), slip opinion, facts found by the Court of Chancery Appeals, quoted p. 3
Earlier courts had struck such acts down: Pennsylvania's court in Godcharles v. Wigeman (1886) called a wages-in-money act an insulting legislative tutelage of the worker. West Virginia's act of 1891, which forbade scrip in paying miners, was upheld in 1892. Supported Little disputed
“More than this, it is an insulting attempt to put the laborer under a legislative tutelage, which is not only degrading to his manhood, but subversive of his rights as a citizen of the United States.”
Robert G. Paterson, Wage-Payment Legislation in the United States, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics Bulletin 229 (Washington, 1918), p. 104, quoting Godcharles & Co. v. Wigeman, 113 Pa. St. 431 (1886)“The Peel Splint Coal Co. violated the act of 1891, which prohibited the use of scrip in payment of miners.”
Robert G. Paterson, Wage-Payment Legislation in the United States, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics Bulletin 229 (Washington, 1918), p. 105
Under the federal Fair Labor Standards Act, a Labor Department rule (text dated 1967) says scrip, tokens and coupons are not proper mediums of payment of wages. Attested Little disputed
“Scrip, tokens, credit cards, “dope checks,” coupons, and similar devices are not proper mediums of payment under the Act.”
Code of Federal Regulations, 29 CFR 531.34, 'Payment in scrip or similar medium not authorized' (eCFR, as of 1 Nov. 2026), 29 CFR 531.34“Source: 32 FR 13575, Sept. 28, 1967, unless otherwise noted.”
Code of Federal Regulations, 29 CFR part 531, source note (eCFR), part 531 source note