An Atlas of Money · All entries
Obsidian blades of northwestern California: wealth, and money?
Attested Disputed
Open on the mapAmong the Yurok, Hupa and Karuk, large blades of obsidian and flint were treasure: held as heirlooms and shown at the great dances. Kroeber (1925) says the largest blades and whitest deerskins far outvalue any of their money, the dentalium shells. He rates blades at 2 to 10 dentalium strings, a 20-inch piece at about $50, and the few giants of 30 inches and more as inestimable. A blade could be part of the payment for a wife from a wealthy family and of the blood money for a man of standing. Powers, who bought small blades at $2.50 apiece in the 1870s, says they passed current also as money; Kroeber and Einzig judge them jewels or precious stones rather than money, because each blade's value varied too much. The unit of reckoning was dentalium. Store of value and payment are shown; use as a medium of exchange is disputed.
No state role recorded
No one's debt

Claims and evidence
Among the Yurok, Hupa and Karuk, large blades of obsidian and flint were held as wealth and shown at the great dances. Kroeber (1925) says the largest blades and the whitest deerskins far outvalue any of their money, the dentalium shells; Powers, in the 1870s, says the large blades were by then kept as ornaments or objects of wealth, brought out at a great dance. Attested Little disputed
“Deerskins of rare colors and large blades of obsidian and flint possessed high values; in fact, all objects carried in dances”
A. L. Kroeber, Handbook of the Indians of California, BAE Bulletin 78 (Washington, 1925), p. 26 (Yurok, 'Treasure')“the largest obsidian and flint blades, and whitest deerskins, far outvalue any of their money”
A. L. Kroeber, Handbook of the Indians of California, BAE Bulletin 78 (Washington, 1925), p. 54 (Yurok Deerskin and Jump dances)“but which nowadays are kept only as ornaments or objects of wealth, to be produced on occasion of a great dance.”
Stephen Powers, Tribes of California, Contributions to North American Ethnology III (Washington, 1877), ch. V (Yurok), on 'the large jasper or obsidian knives which they used to make and use'
Kroeber's list of Yurok valuations rates obsidian or flint blades at 2 to 10 dentalium strings; he gives about $1 an inch for blades of half a foot to a foot, about $50 for a 20-inch piece, and calls the few giants of 30 inches and more inestimable. Powers bought blades about six inches long at $2.50 apiece; the large ones, he says, could not be bought at any price. Attested Little disputed
“Obsidian or flint blades, 2 to 10 strings.”
A. L. Kroeber, Handbook of the Indians of California, BAE Bulletin 78 (Washington, 1925), p. 27, list of Yurok valuations in dentalium strings“A 20-inch piece, however, would be held at about $50, and the few renowned giants that reach 30 and even 33 inches are, from the native point of view, inestimable.”
A. L. Kroeber, Handbook of the Indians of California, BAE Bulletin 78 (Washington, 1925), p. 26 (Yurok)“The large ones cannot be purchased at any price, but I procured some about six inches long at $2.50 apiece.”
Stephen Powers, Tribes of California, Contributions to North American Ethnology III (Washington, 1877), p. 79 (Hupa, ch. VIII)
A blade could be part of a large payment. Kroeber's tariffs put an obsidian, with 10 strings of dentalium, a headband of woodpecker scalps and a boat, in the payment for a wife from a wealthy family, and a red obsidian, with 15 strings and other property, in the price for the killing of a man of standing. Attested Little disputed
“a headband of 50 woodpecker scalps, an obsidian, a boat”
A. L. Kroeber, Handbook of the Indians of California, BAE Bulletin 78 (Washington, 1925), p. 27, the payment for a wife from a wealthy family“red obsidian, a woodpecker scalp headband, and other property, besides a daughter.”
A. L. Kroeber, Handbook of the Indians of California, BAE Bulletin 78 (Washington, 1925), p. 28, the price for the killing of a man of standing ('15 strings, plus, perhaps, a red obsidian ...')
Whether the blades were money is disputed. Powers, who saw them among the Hupa in the 1870s, calls them jewelry for sacred purposes, passing current also as money. Kroeber answers that, because their value varied so greatly with colour, size and workmanship, their civilized equivalents are jewels rather than money; Einzig, following him, calls them precious stones rather than money. Attested Disputed
Contested by Kroeber (1925) and Einzig (1949): jewels or precious stones rather than money, because each blade's value varied too widely
“These are not properly "knives", but jewelry for sacred purposes, passing current also as money.”
Stephen Powers, Tribes of California, Contributions to North American Ethnology III (Washington, 1877), p. 79 (Hupa, ch. VIII)“their civilized equivalents are jewels rather than money”
A. L. Kroeber, Handbook of the Indians of California, BAE Bulletin 78 (Washington, 1925), p. 26 (Yurok)- P. Einzig, Primitive Money in its Ethnological, Historical and Economic Aspects (London, 1949), ch. on North America (his note 87 cites Kroeber)