An Atlas of Money · All entries

Guaycurú and Guaraní: a two-day river market at Asunción, 1542

Commodity · 1542 – 1543 · Río Paraguay at Asunción (Guaycurú from the Chaco bank, Guaraní and Spaniards on the east bank)

Attested Little disputed

Open on the map

Cabeza de Vaca's secretary writes that after the peace of 1542 the Guaycurú came every eighth day with roast venison, fish, cloth and skins, and that 'the markets for the sale of all these commodities lasted two days'. The Guaraní paid in maize, manioc, peanuts, bows and arrows. Two hundred canoes crossed for one market.

Role of the state No state involved

Whose debt No one's debt

The Commentaries were written to defend Cabeza de Vaca after his arrest (1544) and stress his good treatment of Indians, so the scale may be inflated. The English is Domínguez's 1891 translation of the 1555 Spanish. Voluntary barter between hunters and farmers, held under a peace the governor imposed.

Claims and evidence

Barter between groups: after the peace the Guaycurú (Chaco hunters) brought meat, fish, grease, dyed cloth and skins; the Guaraní (farmers) gave maize, manioc, mandubí (peanuts), bows and arrows; the market lasted two days and two hundred canoes crossed for it. Goods were exchanged for goods; no money or unit is named. Attested Little disputed

The market followed a peace imposed by the governor, under which the Guaycurú promised to bring what they took 'to the town for the provisionment of the Spaniards'. Attested Little disputed

Connections