An Atlas of Money · All entries
Bronze Age rings, ribs and axe-blades
Supported Disputed
Open on the mapHoards of thousands of copper-alloy rings and ribs of near-standard shape and weight.
No state involved
No one's debt

Claims and evidence
Rings, ribs and axe-blades from more than 100 hoards are standardised closely enough to have served as early commodity money. Supported Disputed
Contested by readings of the hoards as votive deposits or raw-metal stock
- Kuijpers & Popa, PLOS ONE (2021)
“The analysis shows that 70.3% of all rings could not be perceptibly distinguished from a ring weighing 195.5 grams, indicating their suitability as commodity money. Perceptive weight equivalence is demonstrated between rings, and a selection of ribs and axe blades.”
Kuijpers & Popa, PLOS ONE (2021), p. 1, Abstract“Our findings show that of a total of 2639 rings coming from 113 different hoards, 70.3% (1855 rings) weighed between 176 to 217 grams, making them perceptibly identical to a ring of 195.5 grams.”
Kuijpers & Popa, PLOS ONE (2021), p. 5, Analysis
Rosenswig (2024) argues that money is primarily a unit of account and, on that basis, evaluates recent claims that financial money was integral to the political economies of Bronze Age Europe; he concludes that the orthodox view of money as a medium of exchange inhibits understanding of ancient political economies. Attested Strongly disputed
Contested by Kuijpers & Popa (2021), in this entry: 70.3% of 2,639 rings from 113 hoards weigh within the range perceptibly identical to a 195.5 g ring.
“With this framework of money defined by what gives it value, I then evaluate recent claims that financial money was integral to the political economies of Bronze Age Europe.”
R. M. Rosenswig, 'Understanding money; Or, why social and financial accounting should not be conflated', Economic Anthropology (2024), abstract“I conclude that the adoption of the orthodox assumption that money is primarily a medium of exchange inhibits understanding of what money is and how the political economies of ancient societies were organized.”
R. M. Rosenswig, 'Understanding money; Or, why social and financial accounting should not be conflated', Economic Anthropology (2024), abstract