An Atlas of Money · All entries
London goldsmiths' notes
Attested Little disputed
Open on the mapLondon goldsmiths' promissory notes payable on demand, issued to depositors, came to circulate as means of payment and are the ancestor of the Bank of England note.
No state involved
A claim on an issuer
Claims and evidence
London goldsmiths' promissory notes payable on demand, issued to depositors, came to circulate as means of payment and are the ancestor of the Bank of England note. Attested Little disputed
“their promissory notes payable on demand, which were issued to depositors, had come to be used as a convenient means of making payments”
Bank of England. 1969. 'The Bank of England note: a short history'. Bank of England Quarterly Bulletin 1969 Q2.
London goldsmiths began by keeping merchants' coin for safekeeping, then lent part of it out, on the expectation that only current withdrawal demand need be met in cash, and issued notes that came to exceed the coin held. Attested Disputed
Contested by Selgin (2012, 'Those dishonest goldsmiths', Financial History Review) argues that the goldsmiths were almost certainly not embezzlers: depositors knowingly lent coin at interest, and the 'embezzling goldsmith' is a myth.
“In fact, [goldsmiths] even lent money given them for safe- keeping on the theory and experience that they needed to have on hand only enough to meet the expected, current demand of depositors.”
Huerta de Soto, J. 2006 [Spanish orig. 1998]. Money, Bank Credit, and Economic Cycles, trans. M. A. Stroup. Auburn, Ala.: Ludwig von Mises Institute. Ch. 3 (quoting S. B. Clough).
In Rothbard's 100%-reserve reading, after the Crown's 1638 seizure at the Mint, merchants deposited gold with goldsmiths for safekeeping. By the end of the Civil War the goldsmiths were issuing receipts beyond the gold held and lending them out, which he calls fraud. Supported Strongly disputed
Contested by Selgin (2012): contemporary testimony and English law show depositors knowingly lent coin to goldsmiths at interest, so this was not embezzlement. White's free-banking defence of fractional reserves rests on the same point.
“The English goldsmiths discovered and fell prey to this temptation in a very short time, in fact by the end of the Civil War.”
Rothbard, M. N. 1983. The Mystery of Banking. New York: Richardson & Snyder (Mises Institute edn), ch. VIII.
Selgin argues from contemporary testimony and English law that London goldsmiths almost certainly did not secretly lend coin they were supposed to store. The 'embezzling goldsmith' story confuses them with Crown seizures and merchants' dishonest servants. Supported Strongly disputed
Contested by Rothbard (1983) and Huerta de Soto (1998): fractional-reserve lending of demand deposits was fraud.
“I draw upon both contemporary testimony and contemporary English law to show that the goldsmiths were almost certainly innocent of the crime for which they are so often accused.”
Selgin, G. 2012. 'Those dishonest goldsmiths.' Financial History Review 19(3): 269-288.