An Atlas of Money · All entries
Cigarettes in a WWII POW camp
Attested Little disputed
Open on the mapRadford (1945), an economist and prisoner, observed cigarettes from Red Cross parcels spontaneously becoming the camp currency and price standard; no camp authority decreed it.
No state involved
No one's debt
Claims and evidence
Radford (1945), an economist and prisoner, observed cigarettes from Red Cross parcels spontaneously becoming the camp currency and price standard; no camp authority decreed it. Attested Little disputed
Contested by Berg (2013, blog, New Economic Perspectives) argues the camp is a pure-exchange setting without production, so not a general model of money origination
“Yet our knowledge rests mostly on qualitative evidences that indicate its wide use in prisoners’ camp (Radford, 1945), in post World War II Europe1 (Rosen, 1947) and especially in post war Germany (Friedman 1951, Kindleberger, 1984).”
Radford, R.A., 'The Economic Organisation of a P.O.W. Camp', Economica 12(48) (1945), 189-201; quote via Bignon (2009) p.1
Connections
- Crux: how did money begin?
- Cape Evans, 1911: cigarettes as stakes
- Cape Denison, 1912: chocolate money
- Whaleships: tobacco as currency
- Andersonville: uniform buttons as prices
- Lagergeld in a German officers' camp
- Vorkuta: the bread ration as payment, food by the norm
- Mordovian camps: clothing priced in bread