An Atlas of Money · All entries
Clay tokens and bullae
Attested Little disputed
Open on the mapSmall clay counters for goods (grain, sheep, oil), later sealed inside clay envelopes (bullae). Accounting records of obligations, the precursor of writing.
A claim on an issuer

Claims and evidence
Clay counters for commodities were used across the Near East from c. 8000 BC and sealed in bullae by c. 3500 BC. Attested
- Schmandt-Besserat, Before Writing (1992)
“clay tokens representing units of goods were used for accounting (8000–3500 BC)”
Schmandt-Besserat, 'The Evolution of Writing', International Encyclopedia of Social and Behavioral Sciences (2014), author's copy
The tokens recorded debts and obligations, a ledger, rather than serving as a medium of exchange. Supported Disputed
Contested by Menger (1892) and Mises (1912) on the order of origin: commodity first, accounting after
- Schmandt-Besserat, Before Writing (1992)
“tokens, probably representing a debt, were stored in envelopes until payment”
Schmandt-Besserat, 'The Evolution of Writing', International Encyclopedia of Social and Behavioral Sciences (2014), author's copy
Szabo (2002) reads the sealed token envelopes as bills of lading and warehouse receipts: a claim on goods in store, redeemed by breaking the seal; Sumerian payment itself was in weighed silver and gold rings and coils, not coin. Weak lead Little disputed
“Soon after 4,000 B.C., the clay tokens were combined with the idea of sealing to create bills of lading and warehouse receipts.”
Szabo, N., 'The Playdough Protocols' (2002), Satoshi Nakamoto Institute“The Sumerians used thin wires and flat ingots of gold and silver, carefully weighed in balance scales, rather than coins like the Roman denarius.”
Szabo, N., 'The Playdough Protocols' (2002), Satoshi Nakamoto Institute
The tokens recorded only economic data, one token for each unit of a commodity, and were found mostly in temples and public buildings: at Uruk 88% came from the precinct of Inanna. Supported Little disputed
“Consequently, it appears that the token system was restricted to the recording of exclusively economic data.”
Schmandt-Besserat, D., 'Accounting with Tokens in the Ancient Near East', University of Texas at Austin (web page, archived 25 February 2002)“685 or 88.1% were excavated in the sacred precinct of the goddess Inanna”
Schmandt-Besserat, D., 'Accounting with Tokens in the Ancient Near East', University of Texas at Austin (web page, archived 25 February 2002)
Tokens appear in rank societies and in the graves of high-status people; Schmandt-Besserat reads them as instruments of an elite that controlled redistribution, kept for less than a year and discarded after the harvest. Supported Little disputed
“suggesting that they were used by the elite who controlled the economy of redistribution.”
Schmandt-Besserat, D., 'Accounting with Tokens in the Ancient Near East', University of Texas at Austin (web page, archived 25 February 2002)“This in turn, might suggest that transactions were made in the course of the year to be completed at the time of the harvest.”
Schmandt-Besserat, D., 'Accounting with Tokens in the Ancient Near East', University of Texas at Austin (web page, archived 25 February 2002)