An Atlas of Money · All entries

Clearinghouse loan certificates (1857-1914)

Paper & fiat · 1857 – 1914 · New York City (Wall Street district)

Supported

Open on the map

In panics, member banks pledged collateral to the clearing-house committee for loan certificates used in clearing. In later panics, clearing houses other than New York's also issued them to the public in small denominations.

Role of the state No state involved

Whose debt A claim on an issuer

Gorton & Tallman (2016) add that confidence returned when the currency premium on certified checks went to zero. Griffin treats the certificates as a step toward cartelization. Gorton treats them as successful private crisis insurance. Certificates had no explicit legal sanction until Aldrich-Vreeland (1908). The New York Clearing House Association was founded in 1853 (Calomiris & Gorton p. 119). The requested range starts at 1857. Calomiris & Gorton trace cooperative clearing-house responses from 1857 to 1907, but certificate issues proper run from 1860 (also 1861, 1863-64), then 1873, 1884, 1890, 1893, 1907 and 1914 (Calomiris & Gorton p. 114). This is context rather than the loan-certificate claim: Rothbard praises private clearing as a restraint on overissue, while condemning suspension. The Boston anchor is the

Claims and evidence

In panics, member banks pledged collateral to the clearing-house committee for loan certificates used in clearing. In later panics, clearing houses other than New York's also issued them to the public in small denominations. Supported

Dating: loan certificates in their classic form were first issued in 1860. The 1857 'Metropolitan certificates' were a comparable but different liability. Supported

Opposing (Gorton) reading: in panics the clearing house acted as a lender of last resort, issuing private money and providing deposit insurance. Certificates were joint liabilities that legally united members into a single entity. Supported Disputed

Contested by Griffin 1998; Rothbard 2002

Gorton & Huang: private bank coalitions can act as central banks, but government central banks and deposit insurance historically replaced them. Supported Disputed

Contested by Griffin 1998

Sound-money (Griffin) reading: clearing-house 'script' in 1907 had partial success but no legal foundation. Aldrich-Vreeland (1908) legalized it, and the legal version was used only in 1914. Weak lead Disputed

Contested by Calomiris & Gorton 1991; Gorton & Tallman 2016

Austrian reading of private clearing: the Suffolk system showed that competing private banks can run efficient, safe, inexpensive clearinghouses that limit overissue. Supported Little disputed

Connections