An Atlas of Money · Notes

Silver for silk

The Manila galleon's money

Written by a bot: Claude, an AI model. Every quote is checked against its source.

The Parián of Manila in 1792, drawn by Juan Ravenet on the Malaspina expedition
The Parián of Manila in 1792, drawn by Juan Ravenet on the Malaspina expedition — Ravenet, Juan, 1776-1821 (Expedición Malaspina), CC0

From 1571 to 1815 the Spanish galleons carried silver from New Spain across the Pacific to Manila, where Chinese merchants sold silk for it and refused gold. The crown capped the silver, forced a single buyer on the Chinese for a time, and sold space on the ship by shares, and merchants and officials shipped more than the cap allowed. 5 entries, with the Spanish dollar and Ming paper money for context.

The route

The line between Manila and Acapulco shows only which ports the galleon joined; its course is drawn roughly. Follow a mark to read its entry and sources.

ManilaAcapulcoMexico CityNanjingChinaJapanNew SpainPacific Oceanthe galleon's crossing, drawn roughly

Under the crown's control 3Imposed 1Done despite the crown's rules 1State-issued 2The junks from China, drawn roughlyMarks that share a port are set slightly apart.

Silver for silk

The trade between the Chinese merchants and the Spaniards, as Morga describes it: struck by choice on both sides.

At Manila the Chinese junks sold silk and cloth to the Spaniards, and were paid in silver. Antonio de Morga wrote in 1609: El precio de ordinario de las sedas crudas y tejidas, y manterías, que es lo mas grueso que traen, se hace de espacio, y por personas que lo entienden, así por parte de los Españoles, como de los Sangleyes, y lo que se les da por ellas, es plata y Reales, que no quieren oro, ni otros algunos rescates, ni los llevan á la China (The ordinary price of the silks (both raw and woven) and the cloths--which form the bulk of the cargo--is settled leisurely, and by persons who understand it, both on the part of the Spaniards and that of the Sangleys. The purchase price is paid in silver and reals, for the Sangleys do not want gold, or any other articles, and will not take other things to China.) Antonio de Morga, Sucesos de las Islas Filipinas (Mexico, 1609), ch. VIII; Spanish text in J. Rizal (ed.), Sucesos de las islas Filipinas (Paris, 1890); English from E. H. Blair and J. A. Robertson (eds.), The Philippine Islands 1493-1898, vol. XVI (Cleveland, 1904), ch. VIII, Rizal ed. p. 353

The sale itself was free: sino que el trato sea libre, y los Sangleyes hagan de sus haciendas lo que quisieren. (but the trade must be free, and the Sangleys can do what they like with their property.) Antonio de Morga, Sucesos de las Islas Filipinas (Mexico, 1609), ch. VIII; Spanish text in J. Rizal (ed.), Sucesos de las islas Filipinas (Paris, 1890); English from E. H. Blair and J. A. Robertson (eds.), The Philippine Islands 1493-1898, vol. XVI (Cleveland, 1904), ch. VIII, Rizal ed. p. 353 The Chinese merchants also sold on credit to buyers they trusted: They are ready to trust and accommodate freely whoever they know treats them fairly, and does not fail in his payments to them when these are due. Antonio de Morga, Sucesos de las Islas Filipinas (Mexico, 1609), ch. VIII, transl. in E. H. Blair and J. A. Robertson (eds.), The Philippine Islands 1493-1898, vol. XVI (Cleveland, 1904), vol. XVI, ch. VIII

Not every trader wanted silver as much. Of the Japanese ships Morga writes: el precio es lo mas en reales, aunque no los cudician como los Chinas, por tener plata en Japón, y de ordinario se trae por mercadería cantidad della en planchas, que la dan á precios acomodados. (The price is generally paid in reals, although they are not so greedy for them as the Chinese, for there is silver in Japon. They generally bring a quantity of it as merchandise in plates, and it is sold at moderate rates.) Antonio de Morga, Sucesos de las Islas Filipinas (Mexico, 1609), ch. VIII; Spanish text in J. Rizal (ed.), Sucesos de las islas Filipinas (Paris, 1890); English from E. H. Blair and J. A. Robertson (eds.), The Philippine Islands 1493-1898, vol. XVI (Cleveland, 1904), ch. VIII, Rizal ed. p. 354 And of the Portuguese from Malacca: Purchases of all the above are made in Manila, and paid in reals and gold. Antonio de Morga, Sucesos de las Islas Filipinas (Mexico, 1609), ch. VIII, transl. in E. H. Blair and J. A. Robertson (eds.), The Philippine Islands 1493-1898, vol. XVI (Cleveland, 1904), vol. XVI, ch. VIII

The crown's cap, and how it was evaded

Around that free sale the crown set its own terms. 3 of the 5 entries are marked as under its control, 1 as imposed and 1 as done in spite of it; each says who acted.

The permiso: a cap on the silver 1593–1815 Under the crown's control

A Manila galleon, copperplate in González Cabrera Bueno, Navegación especulativa y práctica, Manila, 1734
A Manila galleon, copperplate in González Cabrera Bueno, Navegación especulativa y práctica, Manila, 1734 — González Cabrera Bueno, José, Public domain

In 1593 the crown let only New Spain trade with the Philippines. In 1604 Felipe III capped the trade: that the quantity of merchandise which may be carried each year from the Philipinas Islands to Nueva España is by no means to exceed two hundred and fifty thousand pesos of eight reals, as is provided; and the return of principal and profit in money is not to exceed five hundred thousand pesos, which I have permitted. Felipe III, Decree regulating commerce with Nueva España, Valladolid, 31 December 1604, transl. in Blair and Robertson, The Philippine Islands, vol. XIII (1904), vol. XIII

The crown also took its duty on each Chinese cargo at Manila: van los oficiales reales á hacer la visita, y registro de las mercaderías que trae, y se hace en forma, y juntamente la avaliación de lo que en Manila valen; porque paga luego tres por ciento, de todo ello á su Magestad (the royal officials go to inspect it and the register of the merchandise aboard it. At the same time the valuation of the cargo is made according to law, of what it is worth in Manila; for the vessel immediately pays three per cent on everything to his Majesty.) Antonio de Morga, Sucesos de las Islas Filipinas (Mexico, 1609), ch. VIII; Spanish text in J. Rizal (ed.), Sucesos de las islas Filipinas (Paris, 1890); English from E. H. Blair and J. A. Robertson (eds.), The Philippine Islands 1493-1898, vol. XVI (Cleveland, 1904), ch. VIII, Rizal ed. p. 353 In 1606 the Audiencia of Manila answered that the cap could not be kept: it is impossible to recover from five hundred thousand pesos the principal and the [present] profits on the investment of the said two hundred and fifty thousand pesos which are granted by this permission. Audiencia of Manila (Telles de Almazán, Alcaraz, de la Vega), letter to Felipe III, Manila, 6 July 1606, transl. in Blair and Robertson, The Philippine Islands, vol. XIV (1904), vol. XIV

Controlled by the Spanish crown: Felipe II's decrees of 1593 and Felipe III's of 1604, through the Council of the Indies, the latter at the petition of the prior and consuls of the merchant guild of Seville. The cap limited how much silver could go from New Spain to Manila; the trade under it was private.

The pancada: a forced purchase 1592–1602 Imposed

For a time the Chinese merchants could sell only to buyers the governor chose. Felipe II's instructions of 1596 describe it: it was resolved that as many persons of the requisite qualifications as were necessary should be deputed and chosen to purchase the said merchandise in the bulk. Felipe II, Instructions for Governor Tello, Toledo, 25 May 1596, transl. in Blair and Robertson, The Philippine Islands, vol. IX (1904), vol. IX The aim was to keep the coin at home: You shall endeavor to traffic for the said merchandise with other products of the islands, so that the exportation of so much coin as is taken to foreign kingdoms may be avoided as far as possible. Felipe II, Instructions for Governor Tello, Toledo, 25 May 1596, transl. in Blair and Robertson, The Philippine Islands, vol. IX (1904), vol. IX

Imposed by the Spanish crown through the governor of the Philippines (Gómez Pérez Dasmariñas, then Francisco Tello) and the deputies he chose to buy the cargoes: the Chinese merchants could sell only to them. The auditors of the Audiencia opposed it.

Boletas: claims on space, backed by sea loans 1604–1815 Under the crown's control

Because space on the galleon was capped and allotted, a share of it became a claim that could be sold. Le Gentil, at Manila in 1766: Ceux qui ne peuvent embarquer faute de facultés, s'arrangent avec d'autres auxquels ils vendent leur port-permis. Les bolètes étoient fort chères en 1766, puisque je les ai vu vendre jusqu'à deux cents & deux cents vingt-six piastres, pendant que selon l'Ordonnance, le principal ne pouvoit être que de cent vingt-cinq (Those who cannot ship for lack of means come to terms with others, to whom they sell their port-permit. Boletas were very dear in 1766, for I saw them sold for as much as two hundred and two hundred and twenty-six piastres, whereas by the ordinance the principal could be only one hundred and twenty-five. (translation for the atlas)) G. J. H. J. B. Le Gentil de la Galaisière, Voyage dans les mers de l'Inde, vol. II (Paris, 1781), art. XIV, vol. II, p. 205

Buyers of many shares borrowed at sea risk, and the loan was owed only if the galleon came back: il faut pour cela une caution qu'on appelle Fiador: c'est le Fiador qui répond de l'argent prêté; mais si le galion ne revenoit point à bon port, il n'est caution de rien. C'est ici le triomphe des Religieux; c'est ici où ils placent l'argent des œuvres pies (a surety called a fiador is needed for it: the fiador answers for the money lent; but if the galleon did not come safe to port, he is surety for nothing. Here is the triumph of the religious; here is where they place the money of the pious works. (translation for the atlas)) G. J. H. J. B. Le Gentil de la Galaisière, Voyage dans les mers de l'Inde, vol. II (Paris, 1781), art. XIV, vol. II, p. 207

Controlled: the shares existed because the Spanish crown capped the cargo and had it allotted (decree of 1604) by the governor, the archbishop, the senior auditor and the fiscal of the Audiencia, and two councillors of Manila. The resale of shares and the sea loans were private.

Evasion: silver shipped beyond the cap 1593–1767 Done despite the crown's rules

Silver 8 reales cob of the Mexico City mint, recovered from the 1715 fleet
Silver 8 reales cob of the Mexico City mint, recovered from the 1715 fleet — Augi Garcia, CC BY-SA 3.0

The crown itself wrote in 1604 that the quantity allowed has been and is being greatly exceeded in the amount taken each year, with the knowledge and permission of my viceroys, audiencias, and governors--goods to the extent of more than two millions of ducats being registered and openly sent, besides what is secretly shipped. Felipe III, Decree regulating commerce with Nueva España, Valladolid, 31 December 1604, transl. in Blair and Robertson, The Philippine Islands, vol. XIII (1904), vol. XIII

A century and a half later Le Gentil saw the same: sur ce pied-là, le galion le Saint-Charles que je vis partir en 1766, portoit pour plus d'un million de piastres de principal en marchandises, ce qui excédoit de beaucoup la permission accordée par le Roi (on that footing the galleon Saint-Charles, which I saw leave in 1766, carried more than a million piastres of principal in goods, far beyond the permission granted by the king. (translation for the atlas)) G. J. H. J. B. Le Gentil de la Galaisière, Voyage dans les mers de l'Inde, vol. II (Paris, 1781), art. XIV, vol. II, p. 205 At Acapulco the cargo met a viceroy who enforced the rules: le galion trouva au Mexique un nouveau Vice-roi; c'étoit le marquis de Croix, Flamand, homme dur, comme disoient les Espagnols, mais qui n'étoit tel à leurs yeux, que parce qu'il étoit exact sur le service du Roi & sur les Ordonnances de Sa Majesté. (the galleon found a new viceroy in Mexico; it was the marquis de Croix, a Fleming, a hard man as the Spaniards said, but he was such in their eyes only because he was strict in the king's service and in His Majesty's ordinances. (translation for the atlas)) G. J. H. J. B. Le Gentil de la Galaisière, Voyage dans les mers de l'Inde, vol. II (Paris, 1781), art. XIV, vol. II, p. 206 La pacotille & les coffres des matelots furent tiercés; deux parties au profit du Roi & la troisième pour le propriétaire: les ballots furent également tiercés, dont une partie au profit du Roi, les deux autres restèrent au commerce. (The private goods and the sailors' chests were divided in thirds, two parts for the king and the third for the owner; the bales were likewise divided in thirds, one part for the king, the other two left to the merchants. (translation for the atlas)) G. J. H. J. B. Le Gentil de la Galaisière, Voyage dans les mers de l'Inde, vol. II (Paris, 1781), art. XIV, vol. II, p. 206

Defied: the merchants of Manila and New Spain shipped silver and goods beyond the crown's cap, with the knowledge of viceroys, audiencias and governors, as the crown itself wrote in 1604. In 1767 the viceroy of New Spain, the marquis de Croix, enforced the ordinances and confiscated part of the cargo for the king.

Why silver, not gold?

Title page of Antonio de Morga, Sucesos de las Islas Filipinas, Mexico, 1609
Title page of Antonio de Morga, Sucesos de las Islas Filipinas, Mexico, 1609 — Antonio de Morga, Public domain

Morga gives no reason, and nothing in his text says gold was forbidden. No Chinese merchant's own reason is in the sources read for this note either. What they do show is a difference in price, and a state that had come to take its taxes in silver.

Spanish officials wrote that silver was what China wanted, and that it was worth more there. The viceroy of New Spain, Martín Enríquez, in 1573: the commerce with that land must be carried on with silver, which they value above all other things Martín Enríquez, viceroy of New Spain, letter to Felipe II, Mexico, 5 December 1573, in E. H. Blair and J. A. Robertson (eds.), The Philippine Islands 1493-1898, vol. III, vol. III A report of the Council of State in 1607 put the drain down to price: it is occasioned by the large profits obtained by investing the silver in the merchandise which comes to those islands from China--partly through the cheapness of these goods, and partly through the great value of silver. Council of State, report on the trade of the Philippines with Mexico, Madrid, 18 December 1607, in E. H. Blair and J. A. Robertson (eds.), The Philippine Islands 1493-1898, vol. XIV, vol. XIV

A memorandum of prices at Canton, printed by Blair and Robertson among papers of the early 1600s, gives the rate there: The tae of fine gold is equivalent to seven of silver. Memorandum of the retail selling prices of wares in Canton (early 17th century), in E. H. Blair and J. A. Robertson (eds.), The Philippine Islands 1493-1898, vol. XIX, vol. XIX, appendix The same papers say the Chinese brought gold to Manila, not only silk: is all brought to Manila by the Chinese themselves, who also bring a great amount of gold, wrought and unwrought, and of different carats. Papers on the trade of the Portuguese and the Philippines (early 17th century), in E. H. Blair and J. A. Robertson (eds.), The Philippine Islands 1493-1898, vol. XIX, vol. XIX, appendix In 1602 the viceroy of New Spain, the Conde de Monterrey, proposed that part of any silver licensed for China buy gold there, and wrote of that gold: The latter is likewise merchandise in China; but traders do not like to take it as it yields them no more than fifty per cent, while on the other merchandise they make five hundred per cent and upward. Conde de Monterrey, extracts of letters to Felipe III (1602), in Various documents relating to commerce, E. H. Blair and J. A. Robertson (eds.), The Philippine Islands 1493-1898, vol. XII, vol. XII

The flow was not one way. The Canton memorandum also says: One million of gold and upward enters China yearly through the Portuguese alone. Papers on the Portuguese trade at Macao (early 17th century), in E. H. Blair and J. A. Robertson (eds.), The Philippine Islands 1493-1898, vol. XIX, vol. XIX, appendix

A Chinese account of the trade and its duties survives in Zhang Xie's 東西洋考 (Dongxi yang kao), written at Zhangzhou in 1617 (the entry on the Haicheng duties gathers its lines). The Fujian office charged every ship back from Luzon a duty on top of the others, because of the silver: 加增餉者,東洋呂宋,地無他產,夷人悉用銀錢易貨,故歸船白銀錢外,無他攜來,郎有貨亦無幾。故商人回澳,徵水陸二餉外,屬呂宋船者,每船更追銀百五十兩,謂之加徵。 (The additional duty: Luzon in the Eastern Ocean has no other products, and the foreigners buy goods entirely with silver coin, so the returning ships bring nothing besides silver coin, and even if they have goods these are very few. So when the merchants come back to port, on top of the water and land duties, every ship from Luzon is charged a further 150 taels of silver; this is called the additional levy. (translation for the atlas)) Zhang Xie 張燮, Dongxi yang kao 東西洋考 (1617, printed 1618), juan 7, Treatise on duties 餉稅考 His reason is that Luzon had nothing else to sell; he does not say why the merchants wanted silver.

Ming silver ingot; Shanghai Museum
Ming silver ingot; Shanghai Museum — Gary Lee Todd, Ph.D., CC0

On the Chinese side, the Ming Shi, the official history of the dynasty, tells how the state's paper money stopped passing and silver took its place (the entry Ming China turns to silver gathers these lines). Of the Xuande reign (1426–35): 戶部言民間交易,惟用金銀,鈔滯不行。 (The Ministry of Revenue said that in the people's trade only gold and silver were used, and the notes were stuck and did not pass. (translation for the atlas)) Ming Shi (History of the Ming, completed 1739), juan 81, Treatise on Food and Money 5 (coin and notes), juan 81 By 1525: 是時鈔久不行,錢亦大壅,益專用銀矣。 (By then the notes had long ceased to pass, copper coin too was clogged, and silver alone came to be used more and more. (translation for the atlas)) Ming Shi (History of the Ming, completed 1739), juan 81, juan 81

The taxes went the same way. Under the Single Whip, the levies were merged and paid in silver: 凡額辦、派辦、京庫歲需與存留、供億諸費,以及土貢方物,悉並為一條,皆計畝徵銀,折辦於官,故謂之一條鞭。 (All the fixed and assigned levies, the yearly needs of the capital treasuries and the funds kept back, the costs of supply, and the local tribute products were merged into one item, all levied in silver by the acreage and handled by the officials; hence it is called the Single Whip. (translation for the atlas)) Ming Shi (History of the Ming, completed 1739), juan 78, Treatise on Food and Money 2 (land tax and labour service), juan 78

Silver was hard for farmers to come by. Xu Guangqi, writing on farming in the late Ming, feared the tax in silver in a good year: 但慮豐年穀賤,公家折色銀,輸納甚艱。民間急宜多種桑株育蠶,擬納折銀可也。 (But I fear that in a good year grain is cheap, and the state's levy commuted into silver is very hard to pay. The people should hasten to plant more mulberry and raise silkworms, so as to pay the commuted silver. (translation for the atlas)) Xu Guangqi 徐光啟, Nongzheng quanshu 農政全書 (1639), juan 27, juan 27 He does not say where the silver came from.

The only ban found in these texts is older, and it fell on both metals. When the first Ming emperor issued his notes, the people were forbidden to trade in gold and silver, to protect them: 禁民間不得以金銀物貨交易,違者罪之;以金銀易鈔者聽。 (The people were forbidden to trade with gold, silver or goods, and offenders were punished; exchanging gold or silver for notes was allowed. (translation for the atlas)) Ming Shi (History of the Ming, completed 1739), juan 81, juan 81

Put together, these sources show three things: silver bought more gold in China than in Spanish lands, so that gold bought there with silver could be sold at a profit; the Ming state had moved its taxes into silver after its notes stopped passing; and the one ban on precious metals they mention was domestic, covered gold as well as silver, and belonged to the early years of the dynasty. None of them says the Chinese merchants were forbidden to take gold from Manila.

What this cannot show