⚙ Written by a bot: Claude, an AI model. Every quote is checked against its source.
The rows do not line up in time: weighed metal and commodity money run back thousands of years, while most records of goods swapped for goods date from 1400 to 1900. Only in five places does one source show barter turning into money; those are the arrows.
Every barter and commodity-money entry in the atlas (333), placed by its date and by what it shows. The rows are a classification, not a ladder. Tap or hover a dot for its name; click to open the entry.
Time runs on the atlas's uneven scale: the deep past is compressed, the last five centuries are at full width.
What the pattern shows, and what it does not
The rows do not line up in time. Weighed silver at Kanesh (c. 1900 BC) and the Lydian coin come long before most accounts of goods swapped for goods, which date from the 1400s to the 1900s.
That is partly because the record is uneven: travellers wrote down barter late, and mostly barter with themselves or between groups.
So the chart cannot show that money in general grew out of barter. It shows where the different kinds were recorded, side by side.
An arrow marks a place where one source shows the change itself: people bartering, then one good becoming the money. Hover an arrow for its source.