The myth of the barter myth
How history shows that money does not need the state
A set of writers, chartalist economists and some anthropologists, hold that barter is a myth: that no society lived by it, that it appears only where money already exists, and that money began as state or temple accounting. Part of this holds. The rest is contradicted by the record.
The claims and the verdicts
| No barter economy has ever been described or found | Partly refuted |
| Barter happens only where money already exists but is scarce, or between strangers | Refuted as “only”; “mainly between groups” supported |
| The barter story is a myth told by economists, from Adam Smith on | Refuted |
| Credit came first, before barter and coin | Not testable for prehistory |
| The first money was accounting (clay tablets, tallies), not metal | Refuted as stated |
| Money is a creature of the state; taxes drive money | Refuted as a general claim; fits some cases |
| The double coincidence of wants never arose because neighbours used credit | Supported inside groups, not between them |
| Money is debt / an IOU | A definition, not a claim of fact |
| Money is primarily a unit of account, not a medium of exchange | A ranking, not a claim of fact; what can be tested goes against it |
Gradations of barter
“Barter” covers more than one thing. The atlas sorts exchange into four kinds, the same four as in From barter to money?. They are a classification, not a ladder that every society climbed.
Barter here means direct exchange: each side takes the other's good to use or consume. The first two kinds are barter. Once a good is taken not to be used but to be passed on, because others will take it in turn, the exchange is indirect and the good is money, as in the last two. Sharing and gifts, with no bargained equivalence, are neither.
Money: indirect exchangea good taken to be passed on
- One good accepted by all. A good taken not to be used but to be passed on: a medium of exchange, which makes it commodity money, not barter. Beads, cloth and wire in Unyamwezi, knives, cloth and arrack on the Kei Islands, cigarettes in a POW camp.
- Weighed metal or coin. Silver weighed at Kanesh, Viking silver cut to weight, and coin.
What holds
- In the groups observed for months or years, exchange inside the group was mostly sharing, gifts that had to be returned and remembered debts; bargained barter was recorded mainly with outsiders (Inside and outside).
- No source watches a whole society move from barter to money over time. That would take generations, and observers stayed weeks or years. Four of the five places where a source shows barter turning into money were camps or an expedition hut, among people who already used money (From barter to money?). What the sources do show, at single moments, is the stage between: barter economies where certain goods already served as the medium or the measure, as on the Kei Islands (knives, cloth and arrack, with tobacco as small change), in Mongolia (sheep and brick tea) and in the Kalahari (tobacco for skins, skins for heifers).
What does not
- That no barter economy has been described: travellers describe several, where the sources report no money.
- That barter appears only where money exists, or only between strangers once: it appears where there was no money, and in trade repeated every year.
- That the barter story was invented by economists: it was written down by historians, explorers and ethnographers.
- That money comes from the state: 246 entries record money with no state involved at all.
Why the barter question matters
The case against barter carries a larger claim. Knapp's premise was that “Money is a creature of law.” Carl Menger had answered the opposite in 1892: “Money has not been generated by law.” “Sanction by the authority of the state is a notion alien to it.” (How did money begin?) If money can arise from trade, from people choosing the good others will most readily take, then money does not need the state. Menger's account does not need a barter economy, only people trading with others who came to prefer one good as the medium. That is what the atlas records where strangers met. Between people who know one another, sharing and credit work; between strangers, a promise is hard to rely on and wants rarely match. A good that anyone will take solves both, and no state is needed for it.
The claims, one by one
1No barter economy has ever been described or found
“we've been scouring the world for over 200 years now and we have never found a single community where everyday transactions take the form of "I'll give you 40 chickens for that cow." They don't exist.”
David Graeber, "Debt: The First 5,000 Years", Talks at Google, 2012 (uploader-supplied English captions), 0:24:22–0:24:35
“What they never found was any place, anywhere, where economic relations between members of community took the form economists predicted: “I’ll give you twenty chickens for that cow.””
David Graeber, "On the Invention of Money – Notes on Sex, Adventure, Monomaniacal Sociopathy and the True Function of Economics" (reply to Robert Murphy), Naked Capitalism, 13 Sep 2011, history §3
“There is no evidence of barter-based markets (outside trivial prisoner-of-war cases), and all the evidence about the origins of money points to state involvement.”
L. Randall Wray, "Modern Money", Levy Economics Institute Working Paper 252, 1998, PDF p. 1
Every barter entry in the atlas with a place, numbered as in the list below. Cadamosto's Senegal of 1455 has no exact place in the atlas and is not drawn.
North America
- Upper Yukon: a gun for its height in furs
- Pitcairn: barter with passing ships
- Fort Okanagan: skins sorted into lots
- Coppermine river: copper for iron
- Copper Inuit: food shared by rule, other things lent, given back or bartered
- Shoshone: horses for a coat and knives
- Andersonville: uniform buttons as prices
- Baffin Island: bearskins for the whalers
- Grenada 1650: the island ceded to the French for trade goods
- Trinidad 1595: tobacco for canoes, and a Spanish ban on trade
- West Greenland: barter as trade and as a game
South America
- Chiloé: tobacco above money
- Cuzco, 1550s: barter in a colonial market without coin
- North-west Amazon: barter and gifts between tribes
- Tierra del Fuego: a nail for two fish
- Yekuana: the elder shares out the catch
- Patagones: Tehuelche barter, rations and beaten dollars
- Taulipáng and Makuschí: food shared, barter on long credit
- Argentine trueque and the crédito
- Guaycurú and Guaraní: a two-day river market at Asunción, 1542
- Asunción's 'moneda de la tierra': wedges, then cotton, tobacco and yerba at legal values
- Francia's Paraguay: licensed trade at Itapúa and a return to exchange
Europe
- Reykjavík: the barter season
- St Kilda: neither gold nor silver
- North Rona: five families, no money
- Ruhleben, 1915: barter notices and confiscated bread
- Sámi: coin taken by weight, silver buried, wealth in reindeer
- Finnmark: Russian (Pomor) meal bartered for fish, one vog for one vog
- Russian barter and veksels
- Mordovian camps: clothing priced in bread
- Tyumen prison: goods for goods with a warder
- Kiakhta: barter by decree
- North-east Siberia: priced in roubles, paid in tea and tobacco
- Chukchi trade standards: tobacco and tea
Africa
- Gambia: barter priced in bars of iron
- Tristan da Cunha: an island without money
- Gabon: bush trade by barter
- Angola: barter priced in the “long”
- Ovambo caravans: beads, iron and copper for Herero cattle
- Herero (Damara) cattle priced in iron: an assegai for an ox
- Great Namaqualand, 1837: cattle for braces, choppers and tinderboxes
- Lake Ngami: ivory for cows; beads and ammunition as trade goods
- Tobacco, skins and cows: the Bakwena kaross trade with the Bakalahari
- Iron hoes as bridewealth currency
Asia
- Hazara highlands: “no money”
- Kafiristan: the cow as standard of value
- Leh: apricots for wool by weight
- Western Tibet: a barter fair
- Sikkim: wool and musk for rice
- Tsaidam: goats for brick tea
- Tea for horses on the Chinese frontier
- Mongolia: sheep, brick tea and squirrel skins as units of account
- Champa: wine and rice, accounts settled yearly
- Sarawak: no money up-country
- Song frontier markets with Liao, Xi Xia and Jin
Oceania
Partly refuted Travellers describe whole trading economies running on barter without money: Senegal, 1455: no coin, all trade by barter, where “all their trade was carried on by way of barter” at the market; Champa: wine and rice, accounts settled yearly; St Kilda: neither gold nor silver and North Rona: five families, no money, bartering among themselves; Hazara highlands: “no money”. Most were short visits, several priced goods in a staple such as cloth or rice, and most traded beside neighbours who used money. What does hold is narrower: none of the 32 long-stay ethnographies in Inside and outside shows a band or village living by bargained barter among themselves.
2Barter happens only where money already exists but is scarce, or between strangers
“Barter, incidentally, tends to only really show up when you have people who are used to using money but actually can't get their hands on any.”
David Graeber, "Debt: The First 5,000 Years", Talks at Google, 2012 (uploader-supplied English captions), 0:41:36
“Or in a prison, they turn cigarettes into money because they're all used to using money.”
David Graeber, "Debt: The First 5,000 Years", Talks at Google, 2012 (uploader-supplied English captions), 0:42:00
“Instead, barter appeared only in societies with existing monetary systems when formal currency was scarce or between strangers for one-off exchanges — not as the foundation of whole economies.”
Robert M. Rosenswig, Michael Parker, "Study: Ancient Tally Sticks Challenge Myths About Money", University at Albany News, 25 Sep 2025 (Rosenswig quoted directly), section "Reassessing Money’s Origins"
Refuted as “only”; “mainly between groups” supported In the long-stay accounts barter is recorded with other groups in 28 of 32 cases and inside the group in 7, among them Trobriands: gimwali, barter pure and simple and Copper Inuit: food shared by rule, other things lent, given back or bartered. But the travellers' accounts above show barter where there was “no money or coin of any kind”, so it was not only where money already existed. Nor was it only one-off: Finnmark: Russian (Pomor) meal bartered for fish, one vog for one vog recurred every summer.
3The barter story is a myth told by economists, from Adam Smith on
“this story was told over 200 years ago -- almost immediately, we started going out in the world trying to find examples of people who do it and we couldn't. It's not true. But they never changed the textbooks.”
David Graeber, "Debt: The First 5,000 Years", Talks at Google, 2012 (uploader-supplied English captions), 0:22:33–0:22:50
“And Adam Smith himself had no way to know this he was just speculating, but now we do and they keep on telling this story.”
David Graeber, "Debt: The First 5,000 Years", Talks at Google, 2012 (uploader-supplied English captions), 0:24:37
“only economists tell the story of barter no other scientists will talk about societies bartering with each other”
Pavlina Tcherneva, Ammous vs Hickel & Tcherneva, "What Is Money? Debating MMTers" (Doha Debates / Bitcoin Standard podcast 351), 10 Nov 2026 (YouTube auto-captions; speaker from host hand-offs), 0:22:11
Refuted Barter was written down long before economists, and by people who were not economists: Strabo on the Dalmatians and inland Iberia, Cadamosto in Senegal in 1455, and Malinowski, who described “bartering, pure and simple” in the Trobriands.
4Credit came first, before barter and coin
“There is no question but that credit is far older than cash.”
A. Mitchell Innes, "What is Money?", Banking Law Journal 30(5), May 1913, pp. 377-408, p. 396
“the idea that to those whom we are accustomed to call savages, credit is unknown and only barter is used, is without foundation.”
A. Mitchell Innes, "What is Money?", Banking Law Journal 30(5), May 1913, pp. 377-408, p. 391
“Remember we have this paradigm: first there is barter, then there's money, then comes credit, and that's wrong. Not only it is wrong, it's actually backwards; credit comes first.”
David Graeber, "Debt: The First 5,000 Years", Talks at Google, 2012 (uploader-supplied English captions), 0:38:02–0:38:08
Not testable for prehistory As a claim about which came first, it cannot be tested: nothing from before writing records how goods changed hands. What can be checked does not settle it. The earliest writing records mostly debts and dues, which fits the claim, but writing was largely invented to keep such accounts. Objects of value and weighed metal are older than writing (Varna gold and spondylus, c. 4600 BC). The long-stay accounts show credit inside the group, debts remembered for months (Siusí, Taulipáng), at the same time as barter with outsiders, not before it. See Crux: how did money begin?.
5The first money was accounting (clay tablets, tallies), not metal
“the very first forms of money that were invented, ancient Mesopotamia, clay tablets, not precious gold, not precious metal.”
Pavlina Tcherneva, Ammous vs Hickel & Tcherneva, "What Is Money? Debating MMTers" (Doha Debates / Bitcoin Standard podcast 351), 10 Nov 2026 (YouTube auto-captions; speaker from host hand-offs), 0:17:25
“money did not originally appear in this cold, metal, impersonal form. It originally appears in the form of a measure, an abstraction, but also as a relation (of debt and obligation) between human beings.”
David Graeber, "Debt: The First Five Thousand Years", Mute vol. 2 no. 12, 10 Feb 2009, section "Towards a History of Virtual Money"
“Tally sticks remind us that money is not a scarce commodity but an accounting system rooted in political authority.”
Robert M. Rosenswig, Michael Parker, "Study: Ancient Tally Sticks Challenge Myths About Money", University at Albany News, 25 Sep 2025 (Rosenswig quoted directly), opening
Refuted as stated The debate notes grade this claim. Valuables and weighed metal are as old as the tablets: Varna gold and spondylus, c. 4600 BC; Kanesh: weighed silver in Old Assyrian trade, weighed silver among private merchants. Uruk accounting tablets and the Exchequer tallies are accounts, and fit the claim for those places.
6Money is a creature of the state; taxes drive money
“Money is a creature of law. A theory of money must therefore deal with legal history.”
Georg Friedrich Knapp, The State Theory of Money (1905; abridged English trans. H. M. Lucas & J. Bonar, Macmillan 1924), p. 1 (ch. I, §1)
“In this approach, money is a creature of the state. The state defines money as that which it accepts at public pay offices (mainly, in payment of taxes).”
L. Randall Wray, "Modern Money", Levy Economics Institute Working Paper 252, 1998, PDF p. 4
“The purpose of taxation is not to finance government spending but to create demand for the currency – hence the term ‘tax-driven money.’”
Pavlina Tcherneva, Pavlina R. Tcherneva, "The Nature, Origins, and Role of Money: Broad and Specific Propositions and Their Implications for Policy", CFEPS Working Paper 46, July 2005, PDF p. 4 (specific proposition 3 of Neo-Chartalism)
Refuted as a general claim; fits some cases 246 entries record money with no state involved: Rai stones, Viking silver paid by weight, Sámi silver and squirrel skins, cigarettes in a POW camp, chocolate in Mawson's hut. Some money was made by the state for its own accounts and taxes, and the atlas marks those too: the Exchequer tallies, Moctezuma's tribute books.
7The double coincidence of wants never arose because neighbours used credit
“If the guy doesn't want my chickens he knows I'm gonna have something he wants because I'm his neighbor, in fact, it's rather nice to have your neighbor in your debt, it's useful for all sorts of things.”
David Graeber, "Debt: The First 5,000 Years", Talks at Google, 2012 (uploader-supplied English captions), 0:25:37–0:25:46
“But without assuming the spot trade, there’s no double coincidence of wants problem, and therefore, no need to invent money.”
David Graeber, "On the Invention of Money – Notes on Sex, Adventure, Monomaniacal Sociopathy and the True Function of Economics" (reply to Robert Murphy), Naked Capitalism, 13 Sep 2011, argument §2a
Supported inside groups, not between them Inside the groups observed for long, neighbours did rely on sharing and remembered debts. Between groups the atlas records haggling and one good becoming the medium: tobacco, skins and heifers in the Kalahari, cigarettes in the camp, chocolate at Cape Denison.
8Money is debt / an IOU
“credit and credit alone is money.”
A. Mitchell Innes, "What is Money?", Banking Law Journal 30(5), May 1913, pp. 377-408, p. 392
“When banks make loans, they create money. This is because money is really just an IOU.”
David Graeber, "The truth is out: money is just an IOU, and the banks are rolling in it", The Guardian, 18 Mar 2014, column
“Money is debt. Anyone can create money. The point is to get it accepted.”
Pavlina Tcherneva, Ammous vs Hickel & Tcherneva, "What Is Money? Debating MMTers" (Doha Debates / Bitcoin Standard podcast 351), 10 Nov 2026 (YouTube auto-captions; speaker from host hand-offs), 0:18:44
A definition, not a claim of fact Whether money “is” debt depends on how money is defined, so it cannot be tested. What can be recorded is whose debt a money was: the atlas marks each entry, and in most entries the money was no one's debt: gold, silver, cattle, shells, skins.
9Money is primarily a unit of account, not a medium of exchange
“Orthodox economists argue that money is primarily a medium of exchange to facilitate trade, whereas chartalists counter that it is, above all else, a unit of account used to administer debits and credits such as taxation.”
Robert M. Rosenswig, "Ancient Tally Sticks Explain the Nature of Modern Government Money", Journal of Economic Issues 59(3), 2025, pp. 663-685 (abstract via Semantic Scholar API), abstract
“Results are shown to be consistent with the chartalist position for the use of financial money by governments in the three unrelated cases.”
Robert M. Rosenswig, "Ancient Tally Sticks Explain the Nature of Modern Government Money", Journal of Economic Issues 59(3), 2025, pp. 663-685 (abstract via Semantic Scholar API), abstract
“Thus, the function of money as a medium of exchange is incidental to and contingent on its first two functions as a unit of account and a means of payment.”
Pavlina Tcherneva, Pavlina R. Tcherneva, "The Nature, Origins, and Role of Money: Broad and Specific Propositions and Their Implications for Policy", CFEPS Working Paper 46, July 2005, PDF p. 4 (broad proposition 6 of Chartalism)
A ranking, not a claim of fact; what can be tested goes against it “Primarily” ranks one function of money above the others, and which function matters most is a judgement, not something the record can show. Money in the atlas serves as a medium of exchange, a unit of account and a store of value, and the atlas names them without ranking them. What can be tested is the stronger form, that exchange is “contingent on” accounts kept by an authority. Many moneys were used in exchange with no such accounts: gold quills at the Tlatelolco market, beads on the Columbia, buffalo robes, cigarettes in a POW camp. Others were held to carry value through time: Sámi silver buried in secret, shell beads at Hochelaga, held “the most precious thing in the world”.