An Atlas of Money · Notes

Money and barter in the Americas

Before and after European contact

Written by a bot: Claude, an AI model. Every quote is checked against its source.

In this atlas the written record of money in the Americas begins with European contact: no entry quotes a text from before it about buying, selling or paying. What is known of earlier times rests on archaeology and on what the first writers reported. Of 263 entries, 2 end before contact in their region, 19 span it and 242 begin after it.

Where the entries are

Each mark is an entry; follow one to read its sources. A single year stands for the first European arrival in each region, so the sorting is coarse: an entry is “at contact” if its dates include that year.

Pacific OceanAtlantic OceanNootkaTenochtitlanCuzcoGuanahaniPotosíAsunción
Before contact 2At contact 19After contact 242Hollow: area named, point approximateMarks that share a place are spread apart, with a thin line back to the true place.
Entries by region, and the contact year used for each
RegionYearBeforeAtAfter
GreenlandNorse settlement of Greenland985003
Alaska and ArcticBering and Chirikov reach Alaska17410012
Pacific NorthwestJuan Pérez reaches Haida Gwaii / Nootka coast1774007
California and Great BasinCabrillo voyage along the California coast1542017
Southwest and northern MexicoCabeza de Vaca party lands1528009
Plains and interior North AmericaCoronado reaches the Plains15410015
Southeast (US)Ponce de León in Florida15130023
Northeast and Great LakesJohn Cabot on the North Atlantic coast14970055
CaribbeanColumbus in the Bahamas, Cuba and Hispaniola14920222
MexicoCortés lands at Veracruz1519085
Yucatán and Central AmericaColumbus on the Honduras coast15021211
Northern South AmericaColumbus on the Venezuelan coast14980018
Andes and Pacific South AmericaRuiz meets a Tumbes raft off Ecuador15261510
Brazil and AmazoniaCabral on the Brazilian coast15000118
Río de la Plata and PatagoniaSolís in the Río de la Plata15160027
All regions219242
All 263 entries, region by region

Greenland

Alaska and Arctic

Pacific Northwest

California and Great Basin

Southwest and northern Mexico

Plains and interior North America

Southeast (US)

Northeast and Great Lakes

Caribbean

Mexico

Yucatán and Central America

Northern South America

Andes and Pacific South America

Brazil and Amazonia

Río de la Plata and Patagonia

Before contact

The record is of objects, and of later writers looking back. How far each counts as money is argued, entry by entry.

Goods could travel far with no evidence of money: nothing links the cacao found at Pueblo Bonito in Chaco Canyon to payment, though Crown and Hurst find that its residue indicates exchange with cacao cultivators in Mesoamerica in a time frame of about A.D. 1000–1125. P. L. Crown and W. J. Hurst, 'Evidence of cacao use in the Prehispanic American Southwest', PNAS 106 (2009), abstract

States without state money

The Mexica took goods that also passed as money. Cotton mantles were paid as fines and tribute, and Bernal Díaz says of Moctezuma: not only did he take tribute from nearly all parts of New Spain, Díaz, transl. Maudslay, vol. 2, vol. 2 The entries show these goods being collected. They do not show the state creating them.

Of the Inca, Garcilaso writes: They exchanged one article of food for another, and no more Garcilaso de la Vega, First Part of the Royal Commentaries of the Yncas, trans. C. R. Markham, vol. 2 (Hakluyt Society, 1869-71), Bk VI ch. 8 He wrote in Spain decades later, from memory and family tradition, and he idealises the Inca state (the entry). Gold was prized and held in great quantity by rulers and temples, but none of these sources shows it buying anything before the conquest. Acosta dates that change: Después que entraron Españoles, usaron también los Indios el oro y plata para comprar (After the Spaniards came in, the Indians also used gold and silver to buy) José de Acosta, Historia natural y moral de las Indias (1590), ed. Madrid 1894, vol. 1, book IV, ch. 3, p. 295 Another source differs on the wider picture: an anonymous account says the Chincha merchants alone in the Inca realm dealt in money, buying food and clothing with copper.

No entry in the atlas records a pre-contact state issuing money or forcing its acceptance. None of the 2 entries before contact carries the atlas's mark for money issued or imposed. Of the 19 at contact, 2 do: the Spanish dollar, a European coin, and Moctezuma's tribute, which records goods taken, not money issued. This is a statement about the record, which is thin. Rosenswig argues the other way, that cacao, cloth and beads were currencies of taxation and that Maya governments used tally sticks as monetary devices; the atlas reports both as his arguments, and they are disputed.

At contact: the first meetings

Most of these first accounts describe goods swapped for goods.

Only 2 of these 8 count as “at contact” on the map. The others are dated after the single year used for their region.

The words

The etymology of money gathers 58 words from 50 Indigenous languages. 13 come from shells or beads and 21 from metals. 12 are borrowed, 9 from Spanish and 3 from English. Sources place only 4 before contact, and 41 cannot be dated. For 6 peoples, writers said there was no money or no use of it, which is not the same as saying they had no word for it.

After contact

Among the 242 entries after contact, 44 are money with no state role recorded; 30 are marked state-issued, 25 imposed and 39 under state licence or control. Each of the examples below carries the atlas's own mark.

Arose in use

Issued, imposed or controlled

What this cannot show

Counted here: entries with dates placed in the Americas, using the regions and contact years listed above. Left out: 8 rows of the hyperinflation table and 2 entries placed only as “the United States”. “Money with no state role recorded” leaves out plain barter, sharing and gifts within a group, running accounts at a store or trading post, single payments, hoards and scenes of exchange.