An Atlas of Money · All entries
Kula ring
Attested Little disputed
Open on the mapShell necklaces and armshells circulate in opposite directions around an island ring as ceremonial gifts. Einzig argues they also serve as stored wealth and a limited medium of exchange.
No state involved
No one's debt

Claims and evidence
Kula valuables circulate as ceremonial gifts, distinct from everyday barter (gimwali). Attested Little disputed
- Malinowski, Argonauts of the Western Pacific (1922)
“The exchange, known under the name of Kula, is effected without any bar- gaining and with the utmost grace and dignity. It serves no economic purpose, for on an early occasion the exchange is reversed. On the other hand, the opportunity of these ceremonial visits is taken for exchanging also goods of practical use by means of ordinary barter on a strictly give-and-take basis.”
Einzig, Primitive Money (1947) [candidate new leg], p. 80“The arm-rings pass from hand to hand as gifts, * gifts in solicita- tion ', as Miss Benedict terms them, and the necklaces travel in the same manner but in a reversed direction. These ornaments are in no sense currency ; they are not used in barter.”
Quiggin, A Survey of Primitive Money (1949) [candidate new leg], p. 18
Kula shell valuables also perform monetary functions: a store of value ('condensed wealth') and a limited medium of exchange. White pearl traders paid native fishers in armshells and Spondylus-disc ornaments. Supported Disputed
Contested by Malinowski (1922); Quiggin (1949): 'in no sense currency'
“There is reason to believe that they are also used as a limited medium of ex- change, notwithstanding Malinowski’s emphatic statement to the con- trary.”
Einzig, Primitive Money (1947), p. 80
Mauss (1925) held that gifts were in theory voluntary but in fact obligatory and returned; he called the vaygu'a a sort of money, a form that preceded ours, but one whose value was still subjective and personal. Supported Little disputed
“les échanges et les contrats se font sous la forme de cadeaux, en théorie volontaires, en réalité obligatoirement faits et rendus.”exchanges and contracts take the form of presents, in theory voluntary, in reality made and returned by obligation. (atlas translation)
M. Mauss, 'Essai sur le don', L'Annee sociologique n.s. 1 (1923-24, publ. 1925); UQAC Classiques des sciences sociales e-text (J.-M. Tremblay, 2002), Introduction, Introduction, 'Programme'; UQAC e-text p. 7“Quelle est la règle de droit et d'intérêt qui, dans les sociétés de type arriéré ou archaïque, fait que le présent reçu est obligatoirement rendu ?”What is the rule of law and interest which, in societies of a backward or archaic type, makes the present received obligatorily returned? (atlas translation)
Mauss, Essai sur le don, Introduction (UQAC e-text), Introduction; UQAC e-text p. 7“L'objet essentiel de ces échanges-donations sont les vaggu'a, sorte de monnaie”The essential object of these exchange-gifts is the vaygu'a, a kind of money. (atlas translation)
Mauss, Essai sur le don, ch. II.2 (kula), UQAC e-text, ch. II, II 'Les Trobriand: le kula'; UQAC e-text p. 30“A mon avis, on ne définit ainsi qu'un second type de monnaie : le nôtre.”In my view, that defines only a second type of money: ours. (atlas translation; 'that' is Malinowski's and Simiand's narrow definition, money as a state-stamped standard of value)
Mauss, Essai sur le don, ch. II, footnote 'Note de principe sur l'emploi de la notion de monnaie', ch. II, n. 'Note de principe'; UQAC e-text p. 30“Dans toutes les sociétés qui ont précédé celles où l'on a monnayé l'or, le bronze et l'argent, il y a ou d'autres choses, pierres, coquillages et métaux précieux en particulier, qui ont été employées et ont servi de moyen d'échange et de paiement”In all the societies that came before those which coined gold, bronze and silver, there were other things, stones, shells and precious metals in particular, that were used and served as a means of exchange and payment. (atlas translation; 'il y a ou' is the e-text's misprint for 'il y a eu')
Mauss, Essai sur le don, 'Note de principe', 'Note de principe'; UQAC e-text p. 30“Leur valeur est encore subjective et personnelle.”Their value is still subjective and personal. (atlas translation)
Mauss, Essai sur le don, 'Note de principe', 'Note de principe'; UQAC e-text p. 30“Il y a donc eu, à notre avis, une forme de monnaie qui a précédé les nôtres.”There was therefore, in our view, a form of money that preceded ours. (atlas translation)
Mauss, Essai sur le don, 'Note de principe', 'Note de principe'; UQAC e-text p. 31“Les vaygu'a des Trobriand, bracelets et colliers, tout comme les cuivres du Nord-Ouest américain ou les wampun iroquois, sont à la fois des richesses, des signes 3 de richesse, des moyens d'échange et de paiement, et aussi des choses qu'il faut donner, voire détruire. Seulement, ce sont encore des gages liés aux personnes qui les emploient, et ces gages les lient.”The vaygu'a of the Trobriands, armshells and necklaces, like the coppers of the American North-West or Iroquois wampum, are at once riches, signs of riches, means of exchange and payment, and also things that must be given away, even destroyed. Only, they are still pledges tied to the persons who use them, and these pledges bind them. (atlas translation; the '3' is a footnote call)
Mauss, Essai sur le don, Conclusion (economic sociology), Conclusion; UQAC e-text p. 98