An Atlas of Money · All entries
Ming China turns to silver
Attested Little disputed
Open on the mapThe Ming Shi, the official history of the dynasty, tells how China came to pay in silver, reckoned by weight. When the first Ming emperor issued his paper notes in 1375, the people were forbidden to trade with gold, silver or goods; the ban was proclaimed again in 1397 and 1448. By the Xuande reign (1426–35) the Ministry of Revenue reported that only gold and silver passed in the people's trade, and the notes did not. At Yingzong's accession the taxes began to be commuted into silver and the ban on silver was relaxed; by 1525 silver alone was used more and more; and under the Single Whip, carried out in full in 1581, the levies were merged and paid in silver. Spanish officials of the galleon years wrote that China valued silver above all other things, and a Canton memorandum puts gold at seven times silver; the same papers say gold went into China too, through the Portuguese. None of these texts gives a Chinese merchant's own reason.
Adopted by a state, not issued by it
No one's debt
Period by period
| Years | Money | Whose debt | Role of the state |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1375–1435 | silver by weight, used in trade despite the ban on gold and silver that protected the notesthe Hongwu emperor's ban on trade in gold, silver and goods (1375), proclaimed again in 1397 | No one's debt | Used despite it |
| 1436–1581 | silver by weight, taken by the state in taxes taxes in grain commuted into silver at Yingzong's accession; the Single Whip, carried out in full in 1581 | No one's debt | Adopted |

Claims and evidence
The Ming Shi records that by the Xuande reign (1426–35) the Ministry of Revenue reported that only gold and silver were used in the people's trade and the notes did not pass, and that by 1525 the notes had long ceased to pass, copper coin was clogged too, and silver alone came to be used more and more. Attested Little disputed
“戶部言民間交易,惟用金銀,鈔滯不行。”The Ministry of Revenue said that in the people's trade only gold and silver were used, and the notes were stuck and did not pass. (translation for the atlas)
Ming Shi (History of the Ming, completed 1739), juan 81, Treatise on Food and Money 5 (coin and notes), juan 81 (Xuande reign, 1426–35)“是時鈔久不行,錢亦大壅,益專用銀矣。”By then the notes had long ceased to pass, copper coin too was clogged, and silver alone came to be used more and more. (translation for the atlas)
Ming Shi (History of the Ming, completed 1739), juan 81, Treatise on Food and Money 5 (coin and notes), juan 81 (fourth year of Jiajing, 1525)
The Ming Shi records that when the notes were first issued, in 1375, the people were forbidden to trade with gold, silver or goods, though gold and silver could be exchanged for notes. The ban on trading with gold and silver was proclaimed again in 1397, the prohibitions again in 1448, and they were relaxed only under Tianshun (1457–64). Attested Little disputed
“禁民間不得以金銀物貨交易,違者罪之;以金銀易鈔者聽。”The people were forbidden to trade with gold, silver or goods, and offenders were punished; exchanging gold or silver for notes was allowed. (translation for the atlas)
Ming Shi (History of the Ming, completed 1739), juan 81, Treatise on Food and Money 5 (coin and notes), juan 81 (eighth year of Hongwu, 1375)“三十年乃更申交易用金銀之禁。”In the thirtieth year the ban on trading with gold and silver was proclaimed again. (translation for the atlas)
Ming Shi (History of the Ming, completed 1739), juan 81, Treatise on Food and Money 5 (coin and notes), juan 81 (thirtieth year of Hongwu, 1397)“十三年復申禁令,阻鈔者追一萬貫,全家戍邊。天順中,始馳其禁。”In the thirteenth year the prohibitions were proclaimed again: whoever obstructed the notes was made to pay ten thousand strings, and his whole family was sent to guard the frontier. Only in the Tianshun reign was the ban relaxed. (translation for the atlas)
Ming Shi (History of the Ming, completed 1739), juan 81, Treatise on Food and Money 5 (coin and notes), juan 81 (thirteenth year of Zhengtong, 1448; Tianshun reign, 1457–64)
The Ming Shi records that at Yingzong's accession the taxes in rice and wheat were commuted into silver and the ban on using silver was relaxed; under the Single Whip all the levies were merged into one item and paid in silver by the acreage. Tried and stopped several times under Jiajing, it was carried out in full in the ninth year of Wanli (1581). Attested Little disputed
“英宗即位,收賦有米麥折銀之令,遂減諸納鈔者,而以米銀錢當鈔,馳用銀之禁。”When Yingzong came to the throne, an order was given to take the taxes in rice and wheat commuted into silver; the payments in notes were then reduced, rice, silver and coin were taken in place of notes, and the ban on using silver was relaxed. (translation for the atlas)
Ming Shi (History of the Ming, completed 1739), juan 81, Treatise on Food and Money 5 (coin and notes), juan 81 (accession of Yingzong; era Zhengtong from 1436)“凡額辦、派辦、京庫歲需與存留、供億諸費,以及土貢方物,悉並為一條,皆計畝徵銀,折辦於官,故謂之一條鞭。”All the fixed and assigned levies, the yearly needs of the capital treasuries and the funds kept back, the costs of supply, and the local tribute products were merged into one item, all levied in silver by the acreage and handled by the officials; hence it is called the Single Whip. (translation for the atlas)
Ming Shi (History of the Ming, completed 1739), juan 78, Treatise on Food and Money 2 (land tax and labour service), juan 78“立法頗為簡便。嘉靖間,數行數止”The method was quite simple. In the Jiajing reign it was put in force and stopped several times (translation for the atlas)
Ming Shi (History of the Ming, completed 1739), juan 78, Treatise on Food and Money 2 (land tax and labour service), juan 78 (Jiajing reign, 1522–66; carried out in full in the ninth year of Wanli, 1581)
Spanish officials wrote that silver was what China wanted and that it was worth more there: the viceroy Enríquez in 1573 that the Chinese valued it above all other things; a view recorded by the Council of State in 1607 that the drain of silver came from the cheapness of Chinese goods and the great value of silver; and the viceroy Monterrey in 1602 that gold bought in China yielded traders no more than fifty per cent, against five hundred and more on other goods. Attested Little disputed
“the commerce with that land must be carried on with silver, which they value above all other things”
Martín Enríquez, viceroy of New Spain, letter to Felipe II, Mexico, 5 December 1573, in E. H. Blair and J. A. Robertson (eds.), The Philippine Islands 1493-1898, vol. III, vol. III“it is occasioned by the large profits obtained by investing the silver in the merchandise which comes to those islands from China--partly through the cheapness of these goods, and partly through the great value of silver.”
Council of State, report on the trade of the Philippines with Mexico, Madrid, 18 December 1607, in E. H. Blair and J. A. Robertson (eds.), The Philippine Islands 1493-1898, vol. XIV, vol. XIV“The latter is likewise merchandise in China; but traders do not like to take it as it yields them no more than fifty per cent, while on the other merchandise they make five hundred per cent and upward.”
Conde de Monterrey, extracts of letters to Felipe III (1602), in Various documents relating to commerce, E. H. Blair and J. A. Robertson (eds.), The Philippine Islands 1493-1898, vol. XII, vol. XII
A memorandum of prices at Canton, of the early 1600s, gives a tael of fine gold as worth seven of silver. The same papers say gold also went into China: a million and more a year through the Portuguese alone. Attested Little disputed
“The tae of fine gold is equivalent to seven of silver.”
Memorandum of the retail selling prices of wares in Canton (early 17th century), in E. H. Blair and J. A. Robertson (eds.), The Philippine Islands 1493-1898, vol. XIX, vol. XIX, appendix“One million of gold and upward enters China yearly through the Portuguese alone.”
Papers on the Portuguese trade at Macao (early 17th century), in E. H. Blair and J. A. Robertson (eds.), The Philippine Islands 1493-1898, vol. XIX, vol. XIX, appendix
Connections
- Da Ming Baochao
- Manila, 1571–1815: Chinese silk for silver reals
- Acapulco and Manila, 1593–1767: silver shipped beyond the cap
- Spanish dollar (piece of eight) as world money
- Potosí silver and its mint: cob coins behind the Spanish dollar
- Yuan paper money (chao)
- Haicheng (Yuegang), 1567–1617: licences and silver duties on the Luzon trade