An Atlas of Money · All entries

Ming China turns to silver

Weighed metal · 1375 – 1581 · Beijing (the Ming court)

Attested Little disputed

Open on the map

The Ming Shi, the official history of the dynasty, tells how China came to pay in silver, reckoned by weight. When the first Ming emperor issued his paper notes in 1375, the people were forbidden to trade with gold, silver or goods; the ban was proclaimed again in 1397 and 1448. By the Xuande reign (1426–35) the Ministry of Revenue reported that only gold and silver passed in the people's trade, and the notes did not. At Yingzong's accession the taxes began to be commuted into silver and the ban on silver was relaxed; by 1525 silver alone was used more and more; and under the Single Whip, carried out in full in 1581, the levies were merged and paid in silver. Spanish officials of the galleon years wrote that China valued silver above all other things, and a Canton memorandum puts gold at seven times silver; the same papers say gold went into China too, through the Portuguese. None of these texts gives a Chinese merchant's own reason.

Role of the state, 1436–1581 (earlier periods below) Adopted by a state, not issued by it

Whose debt, 1436–1581 (earlier periods below) No one's debt

Period by period

YearsMoneyWhose debtRole of the state
1375–1435silver by weight, used in trade despite the ban on gold and silver that protected the notesthe Hongwu emperor's ban on trade in gold, silver and goods (1375), proclaimed again in 1397No one's debtUsed despite it
1436–1581silver by weight, taken by the state in taxes (the prohibitions were proclaimed again in 1448 and relaxed under Tianshun, 1457–64)taxes in grain commuted into silver at Yingzong's accession; the Single Whip, carried out in full in 1581No one's debtAdopted
Ming silver ingot; Shanghai Museum
Ming silver ingot; Shanghai Museum — Gary Lee Todd, Ph.D., CC0

Claims and evidence

The Ming Shi records that by the Xuande reign (1426–35) the Ministry of Revenue reported that only gold and silver were used in the people's trade and the notes did not pass, and that by 1525 the notes had long ceased to pass, copper coin was clogged too, and silver alone came to be used more and more. Attested Little disputed

The Ming Shi records that when the notes were first issued, in 1375, the people were forbidden to trade with gold, silver or goods, though gold and silver could be exchanged for notes. The ban on trading with gold and silver was proclaimed again in 1397, the prohibitions again in 1448, and they were relaxed only under Tianshun (1457–64). Attested Little disputed

The Ming Shi records that at Yingzong's accession the taxes in rice and wheat were commuted into silver and the ban on using silver was relaxed; under the Single Whip all the levies were merged into one item and paid in silver by the acreage. Tried and stopped several times under Jiajing, it was carried out in full in the ninth year of Wanli (1581). Attested Little disputed

Spanish officials wrote that silver was what China wanted and that it was worth more there: the viceroy Enríquez in 1573 that the Chinese valued it above all other things; a view recorded by the Council of State in 1607 that the drain of silver came from the cheapness of Chinese goods and the great value of silver; and the viceroy Monterrey in 1602 that gold bought in China yielded traders no more than fifty per cent, against five hundred and more on other goods. Attested Little disputed

A memorandum of prices at Canton, of the early 1600s, gives a tael of fine gold as worth seven of silver. The same papers say gold also went into China: a million and more a year through the Portuguese alone. Attested Little disputed

Connections