An Atlas of Money · All entries
Acapulco and Manila, 1593–1767: silver shipped beyond the cap
Attested Little disputed
Open on the mapThe crown's cap on the galleon trade was exceeded from the start. Felipe III's decree of 1604 says the quantity allowed had been and was being greatly exceeded with the knowledge of his viceroys, audiencias and governors, goods worth more than two million ducats being registered and openly sent, besides what went secretly. A paper of about 1602 says the Santo Tomás was lost with two millions or more of silver besides the 500,000 pesos allowed. In 1731 the officials of Acapulco reported sums sent to the Philippines beyond the permitted amount on various warrants, and 1,691,465 pesos embarked in one year as proceeds of the fair, when the permission, raised in 1702, allowed 600,000 of returns. Le Gentil saw the Saint-Charles leave Manila in 1766 with more than a million piastres of goods, far beyond the permission; at Acapulco the new viceroy, the marquis de Croix, took two thirds of the sailors' goods and a third of the bales for the king.
Used despite state rules
No one's debt

Claims and evidence
Felipe III's decree of 1604 says the quantity allowed had been and was being greatly exceeded every year with the knowledge and permission of his viceroys, audiencias and governors, goods worth more than two million ducats being registered and openly sent, besides what was shipped secretly. Attested Little disputed
“the quantity allowed has been and is being greatly exceeded in the amount taken each year, with the knowledge and permission of my viceroys, audiencias, and governors--goods to the extent of more than two millions of ducats being registered and openly sent, besides what is secretly shipped.”
Felipe III, Decree regulating commerce with Nueva España, Valladolid, 31 December 1604, transl. in Blair and Robertson, The Philippine Islands, vol. XIII (1904), vol. XIII
A pamphlet of about 1602 says the Santo Tomás was lost with two millions or more of silver, besides the 500,000 pesos allowed to be carried. Attested Little disputed
“the hulk was lost with some supplies, small wares, and two millions or more of silver, besides the 500,000 pesos which were allowed to be carried.”
Alonso Fernández de Castro, Principal points in regard to the trade of the Filipinas [printed pamphlet, 1602?], transl. in Blair and Robertson, The Philippine Islands, vol. XII (1904), vol. XII, p. 46 ff.
In Blair and Robertson's summary of the Acapulco reports of 1731, the castellan says that for ten years many sums of money had gone to the Philippines outside the permitted amount on various warrants, and the royal officials give the silver embarked that year as 1,691,465 pesos from the goods sold at the fair, when the permission, raised in 1702, allowed 300,000 pesos of capital and 600,000 of returns. Supported Little disputed
“That for the last ten years many sums of money had gone to Philipinas outside of the permitted amount, on various warrants, for which orders had been previously given, regarding which the bureau of accounts could supply information”
Castellan and royal officials of Acapulco, reports to the viceroy Casa-Fuerte (1731), in the synopsis of Blair and Robertson, The Philippine Islands, vol. XLV (1906), vol. XLV, synopsis“1,691,465 pesos, as proceeds of the merchandise sold at the fair that year”
Royal officials of Acapulco, report of 1731, in the synopsis of Blair and Robertson, The Philippine Islands, vol. XLV (1906), vol. XLV, synopsis“That in the year 1702 their permission had been increased to 300,000 pesos of capital [invested], and 600,000 of returns”
Castellan of Acapulco, report (1731), in the synopsis of Blair and Robertson, The Philippine Islands, vol. XLV (1906), vol. XLV, synopsis
Le Gentil saw the galleon Saint-Charles leave Manila in 1766 with more than a million piastres of goods, far beyond the king's permission. At Acapulco it met a new viceroy, the marquis de Croix, who kept to the king's ordinances: the sailors' private goods were divided in thirds, two for the king, and a third of the bales went to the king. Attested Little disputed
“sur ce pied-là, le galion le Saint-Charles que je vis partir en 1766, portoit pour plus d'un million de piastres de principal en marchandises, ce qui excédoit de beaucoup la permission accordée par le Roi”on that footing the galleon Saint-Charles, which I saw leave in 1766, carried more than a million piastres of principal in goods, far beyond the permission granted by the king. (translation for the atlas)
G. J. H. J. B. Le Gentil de la Galaisière, Voyage dans les mers de l'Inde, vol. II (Paris, 1781), art. XIV, vol. II, p. 205“le galion trouva au Mexique un nouveau Vice-roi; c'étoit le marquis de Croix, Flamand, homme dur, comme disoient les Espagnols, mais qui n'étoit tel à leurs yeux, que parce qu'il étoit exact sur le service du Roi & sur les Ordonnances de Sa Majesté.”the galleon found a new viceroy in Mexico; it was the marquis de Croix, a Fleming, a hard man as the Spaniards said, but he was such in their eyes only because he was strict in the king's service and in His Majesty's ordinances. (translation for the atlas)
G. J. H. J. B. Le Gentil de la Galaisière, Voyage dans les mers de l'Inde, vol. II (Paris, 1781), art. XIV, vol. II, p. 206“La pacotille & les coffres des matelots furent tiercés; deux parties au profit du Roi & la troisième pour le propriétaire: les ballots furent également tiercés, dont une partie au profit du Roi, les deux autres restèrent au commerce.”The private goods and the sailors' chests were divided in thirds, two parts for the king and the third for the owner; the bales were likewise divided in thirds, one part for the king, the other two left to the merchants. (translation for the atlas)
G. J. H. J. B. Le Gentil de la Galaisière, Voyage dans les mers de l'Inde, vol. II (Paris, 1781), art. XIV, vol. II, p. 206
Connections
- The Manila galleon, 1593–1815: the crown's cap on silver (permiso)
- Manila, 1604–1815: boletas, shares of galleon space sold and pledged
- Manila, 1571–1815: Chinese silk for silver reals
- Potosí silver and its mint: cob coins behind the Spanish dollar
- Ming China turns to silver
- Haicheng (Yuegang), 1567–1617: licences and silver duties on the Luzon trade