An Atlas of Money · All entries

Exchequer tally sticks

Credit & ledger · 1179 – 1826 · Westminster

Attested Little disputed

Open on the map

Notched hazel sticks cut at the Exchequer of Receipt as receipts for money paid in, mainly by sheriffs; the payer kept the stock, the Exchequer the foil. From about 1320 the Exchequer also handed out receipt tallies to creditors as orders on revenue collectors (assignment). By the 17th century goldsmiths discounted them and they traded below face value. Cutting ended in October 1826. Burning the old stock set fire to Parliament in 1834.

Role of the state State-issued

Whose debt A claim on an issuer

Medieval English tally sticks: notched, inscribed and split, as the Exchequer's were. Winchester City Council Museums.
Medieval English tally sticks: notched, inscribed and split, as the Exchequer's were. Winchester City Council Museums. — Winchester City Council Museums, CC BY-SA 2.0

The start year is the Dialogus de Scaccario (c. 1179), the earliest description of Exchequer tallies here; it says the court was formerly called 'the tallies', so the practice is older. No earlier date (such as 1100) is attested in the sources quoted. Wood: Dickens (1855) says elm; Jenkinson (1911) says usually hazel. Size: the 1694 Bank of England tally is about 4 ft long and records £18,812 13s 11½d of the £1.2 million subscription; the 8 ft 6 in sticks are late-18th-century. Per-tally limits of £25,000 (Chisholm) and later £50,000 argue against one stick for £1.2 million.

Claims and evidence

Split tallies recorded and transferred Crown debts for seven centuries. Attested Little disputed

The Dialogus de Scaccario (c. 1179) describes tallies cut at the lower Exchequer (the Receipt) when money was paid in. Its notches stood for sums: a palm's width for £1000, a thumb's for £100, a barley grain for £1, a plain cut for a penny. Attested Little disputed

The Dialogus treats tallies as older than the chequered cloth: the court once called 'the exchequer' was formerly called 'the tallies'. Attested Little disputed

Sheriffs brought their counter-tallies to the account. A sheriff holding a tally was not acquitted until it was entered on the roll. The sheriff also handed in tallies of debtors. Attested Little disputed

Jenkinson (1911) says Exchequer tallies were usually made of hazel and that the payer kept the stock while the Exchequer kept the foil. He says the rules stayed the same from the 12th century until the 19th, and that tallies continued to be cut until October 1826. Supported Little disputed

Assignment: from about 1320 the Exchequer also gave receipt tallies to creditors as orders on revenue collectors. Jenkinson says such a tally could become in effect a cheque payable to bearer. Supported Little disputed

Jenkinson (1925) infers that so many tallies were issued by assignment that private firms must have discounted them. Supported Little disputed

Jenkinson (1925) holds that a tally was and always remained a receipt for a payment, though in use it could become hardly distinguishable from a cheque payable to bearer. Supported Disputed

Contested by Innes (1913), in this entry, who calls tallies 'transferable, negotiable instruments, just like bills of exchange, bank-notes or coins'

17th century: Jenkinson says the goldsmiths discounted tallies and that the king caused a panic by stopping the Exchequer; Evelyn records the Stop (March 1672) as ruining 'many widows and orphans'. In July 1696 Evelyn could not sell £2000 of Exchequer tallies even at a 30% discount. Attested Little disputed

Bank of England, 1694: the public subscribed £1.2 million to lend to the government. The Bank's museum displays a 1694 hazel tally recording one of its first loans to the government. One reported 1694 tally, 4 ft ¾ in long, records £18,812 13s 11½d of the original subscription. Attested Little disputed

Jenkinson (1925): stocks of late-18th-century tallies found at the Bank of England reach 8 ft 6 in. They stayed at the Bank because they were receipts for part of the original Government Debt (the £11,015,100 of the weekly Bank Return), which 'has never been repaid'. Chisholm (as cited in Jenkinson 1911) gives a later length limit of 5 ft and says no more than about £25,000 was usually cut on one tally. Supported Little disputed

The old tallies were burnt in 1834 in a stove in the House of Lords, which set fire to both Houses. Dickens told the story in a speech of 1855. Attested Little disputed

Rosenswig (2025) argues that English, Chinese and Maya governments used tally sticks as monetary devices, consistent with the chartalist view; his university's summary says sheriffs issued hazelwood sticks to record tax obligations for the Exchequer. Attested Strongly disputed

Contested by The Dialogus de Scaccario and Jenkinson, in this entry: the Exchequer's chamberlains cut tallies as receipts for money paid in, mostly by sheriffs, who kept the stock; they recorded payments made, not obligations assessed.

Connections